- #36
Stoonroon
- 11
- 0
Gravity probe B is in orbit over Earth's surface. It has provided nice support for predictions of General Relativity involving a couple of its minute deviations from Newton's predictions for this exterior, "weak field" circumstance.
General Relativity, of course, also predicts simple harmonic motion for the interior, through-the-center circumstance. But this particular interior field prediction remains to be tested, whether in the context of Einsteinian or Newtonian gravity.
It may be relevant to point out that in General Relativity, the prediction can be expressed in terms of clock rate. The theory says that a clock at rest at the center would have the slowest rate of all stationary clocks attached to the mass. What physical mechanism makes the central clock go slow?
I'm not saying that it doesn't. I'm just pointing out that nobody has ever proven that it does. It's easy to understand that one would extrapolate the concept of gravity (whether in terms of Newtonian "potential" or relativistic spacetime curvature) from the exterior to the interior. But theoretical extrapolation is a poor substitute for physical fact.
General Relativity, of course, also predicts simple harmonic motion for the interior, through-the-center circumstance. But this particular interior field prediction remains to be tested, whether in the context of Einsteinian or Newtonian gravity.
It may be relevant to point out that in General Relativity, the prediction can be expressed in terms of clock rate. The theory says that a clock at rest at the center would have the slowest rate of all stationary clocks attached to the mass. What physical mechanism makes the central clock go slow?
I'm not saying that it doesn't. I'm just pointing out that nobody has ever proven that it does. It's easy to understand that one would extrapolate the concept of gravity (whether in terms of Newtonian "potential" or relativistic spacetime curvature) from the exterior to the interior. But theoretical extrapolation is a poor substitute for physical fact.