How to Solve Quantum Mechanics Problems Using Commutation Relations

  • Thread starter kib97153
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the use of the commutation relation of the position operator and the Hamiltonian, but the person trying to use it has failed. Another person suggests using the commutator trick by multiplying the left hand side by the energy denominator and inserting the Hamiltonian operator. The original poster is unsure if this is the correct procedure and asks for clarification, but later realizes they have successfully solved the problem.
  • #1
kib97153
4
0
http://ejokeimg.pchome.com.tw/see-post.html?Flow_No=30201&cat=47&rank="

I try using the commutation relation of the position operator and the Hamiltonian, but failed.:bugeye::bugeye:

Thanks for your kindly help!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
By the way, I don't know how to show the pics directly, sorry about that.
 
  • #3
Multiply the left hand side by the energy denominator. Insert the hamiltonian operator. The commutator trick should then work.
 
  • #4
StatMechGuy said:
Multiply the left hand side by the energy denominator. Insert the hamiltonian operator. The commutator trick should then work.


Thanks for your reply.^^ You mean like this?
But it's not the original equation. I know that the commutator of position and Hamiltonian is equal to velocity multiplies by
i and hbar(positive or negative sign added). But what I want to know is how to transform the position operator "itself" into the "velocity form" in the first pic I posted. Or my procedure is simply incorrect?
 

Attachments

  • rtov1.JPG
    rtov1.JPG
    3 KB · Views: 424
  • rtov2.JPG
    rtov2.JPG
    3.4 KB · Views: 412
  • rtov3.JPG
    rtov3.JPG
    2.6 KB · Views: 469
Last edited:
  • #5
Ooooooooooops, I got through it, thanks for you help!
You are right! No further questions at all...
 

FAQ: How to Solve Quantum Mechanics Problems Using Commutation Relations

Can anyone show me how to use this equipment?

Yes, someone can definitely show you how to use the equipment. It would be best to ask a colleague or supervisor who is familiar with the equipment for a demonstration. You can also refer to the instruction manual or search for tutorials online.

Can anyone show me how this experiment is done?

Absolutely, someone can show you how the experiment is done. It would be helpful to ask a fellow scientist who has experience with similar experiments. You can also refer to published research studies or consult with your supervisor for guidance.

Can anyone show me how to interpret these results?

Yes, someone can definitely help you interpret the results. It would be best to consult with a statistician or someone with expertise in data analysis. You can also refer to statistical software or textbooks for guidance.

Can anyone show me how to replicate this study?

Yes, someone can show you how to replicate the study. It would be helpful to consult with the original researchers or someone who has successfully replicated the study before. You can also refer to published protocols or guidelines for replicating scientific studies.

Can anyone show me how to troubleshoot this experiment?

Yes, someone can show you how to troubleshoot the experiment. It would be best to consult with someone who has experience with the same experiment or similar equipment. You can also refer to troubleshooting guides or seek help from the manufacturer of the equipment.

Similar threads

Back
Top