How Is Toughness Different from Strength in Materials?

  • Thread starter shalu
  • Start date
In summary: It describes how much force it takes to deform the material in a particular direction. In summary, Strength relates to how much force is needed to break a sample, while toughness relates to how much energy is needed to break the sample. However, these properties do not always correspond to practical differences. For example, engineering ceramics are brittle while structural steels are ductile.
  • #1
shalu
8
0
hai everybody,
how is toughness different from strength??
from physics point of view, strength tells about how much force is needed to break a sample and toughness tells about how much energy is needed to break the sample
but that doesn't really tell what are the practical differences??
if the material is strong as well as it is tough also
what the difference
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
Strength is usually the ultimate tensile stress - how much force per unit area it requires to break. Toughness is the resistance to starting to fracture.
Generally tough materials deform to reduce local stress and so don't break as easily.
 
  • #3
Supplementing mgb_phys's response -

Strength is related to the resistance to deformation. Stronger materials have lower strains for a given load/stress, or greater elastic modulus.

Toughness is the resistance to fracture or resistance to crack nucleation and propagation. In many applications, there is usually an assumption of a pre-existing flaw, e.g. a void or inclusion where stress accumulation could nucleate a crack.

Tough materials usually have some amount of plasticity ahead of crack tip, which "blunts" the crack tip and reduces the stress concentration.
 
  • #4
Strength is (loosely) the maximum force the component can take; toughness is the energy needed to make it fail.

Examples:

engineering ceramics are brittle, i.e they can't sustain much plastic deformation before they fracture. They have high strength but low toughness. They can take high static forces but are susceptible to, for example, impact loads.

structural steels are ductile, i.e they undergo considerable plastic deformation before they fracture. They have lower strength but higher toughness. They are then much more tolerant of impacts.

Ideally, we'd like high strength and high toughness but getting both in one material is difficult.

The third mechanical property is stiffness. That's independent of strength and toughness.
 

FAQ: How Is Toughness Different from Strength in Materials?

What is the difference between toughness and strength?

Toughness and strength are two different properties of materials that are often confused with each other. Toughness refers to a material's ability to resist fracture or breakage, while strength refers to a material's ability to withstand external forces without deforming or breaking. In other words, toughness measures a material's ability to absorb energy before breaking, while strength measures its ability to resist deformation.

How are toughness and strength measured?

Toughness and strength are measured using different tests and units. Toughness is typically measured using impact tests, where a material is subjected to a sudden impact and the amount of energy absorbed before breaking is measured. Strength, on the other hand, is measured using tensile or compressive tests, where a material is pulled or pushed until it breaks. The units of toughness are energy per unit volume, such as Joules per cubic meter, while the units of strength are force per unit area, such as Newtons per square meter.

Can a material be tough but not strong, or vice versa?

Yes, a material can be tough but not strong, or strong but not tough. For example, rubber is tough because it can absorb a lot of energy before breaking, but it is not very strong because it can be easily stretched or deformed. On the other hand, glass is strong because it can withstand a lot of force before breaking, but it is not very tough because it can shatter easily without absorbing much energy.

Which is more important, toughness or strength?

The importance of toughness and strength depends on the specific application and requirements of a material. In some cases, toughness may be more important, such as in materials used for impact-resistant applications like car bumpers. In other cases, strength may be more important, such as in materials used for structural applications like bridges and buildings. Ideally, a material should have both high toughness and high strength for optimal performance.

Can toughness and strength be improved?

Yes, both toughness and strength can be improved through various methods such as altering the chemical composition of a material, changing its microstructure, or introducing reinforcements like fibers or particles. However, there is often a trade-off between toughness and strength, meaning that improving one property may result in a decrease in the other. Therefore, it is important for scientists and engineers to carefully consider the specific requirements of a material before attempting to improve its toughness or strength.

Similar threads

Back
Top