HUP and the Double-Slit Experiment

In summary, the conversation discusses a double-slit experiment using an optical laser. The experiment is set up far enough from the slits to guarantee a large uncertainty in position, resulting in an interference pattern. It is debated whether moving the laser closer to the slits would cause the interference pattern to disappear due to the decrease in uncertainty. The use of quantum theory is questioned, but classical electrodynamics can also be used to calculate the behavior. Exact solutions of the Maxwell equations are difficult, but Kirchhoff's theory of refraction can be used as a simple approximation.
  • #1
LarryS
Gold Member
352
33
Consider the following double-slit experiment: The source is an optical laser. The beam is, say, ½-inch wide and the laser is located far enough, say 10 yards, from the 2 slits to guarantee a large uncertainty in position (because of the very small uncertainty in the momentum direction). Obviously, the half-inch wide beam must cover the 2 slits.

I believe the above experiment would produce the classic interference pattern.

Now imagine moving the laser source closer and closer to the 2 slits so that the uncertainty in the momentum direction slowly increases. Would there be some point (distance between laser source and the 2 slits) at which the interference pattern would disappear because the experimental setup would no longer guarantee a large uncertainty in position?

As always, thanks in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
As long as both slits are illuminated and we'll have an interference pattern.

It is generally best to calculate the pattern using the methods of wave mechanics. The uncertainty principle is baked into the mathematical formalism of the wave equation; invoking it directly here is primarily a way of satisfying ourselves that the calculated behavior is physically reasonable.
 
  • #3
Well, here you don't need quantum theory. Classical electrodynamics will do fine. A laser emits a pretty nice coherent wave-train you can treat as a plane wave for this purpose. The most simple approximation is Kirchhoff's theory of refraction. Exact solutions of the Maxwell equations, including all boundary conditions and polarization is pretty tough. For the half-plane it has been solved first by Sommerfeld (in his habilitation thesis if I remember right). Sommerfeld's lecture notes are a good source, but the optics volume is a particular gem!
 

FAQ: HUP and the Double-Slit Experiment

1. What is the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle (HUP)?

The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle is a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics that states that it is impossible to know both the exact position and momentum of a particle at the same time. This means that there is a limit to the precision with which we can measure these properties, and the more precisely we know one, the less precisely we can know the other.

2. How does the Double-Slit Experiment relate to the HUP?

The Double-Slit Experiment is a thought experiment that demonstrates the principles of superposition and wave-particle duality, which are key concepts in quantum mechanics. The experiment involves shooting particles, such as photons or electrons, through two parallel slits and observing the resulting interference pattern. This experiment shows that particles can behave like waves, and their position and momentum cannot be known simultaneously, thus illustrating the HUP.

3. What is the significance of the Double-Slit Experiment?

The Double-Slit Experiment is significant because it provides evidence for the strange behavior of particles at the quantum level and challenges our classical understanding of the physical world. It also supports the idea that particles can exist in multiple states simultaneously and that our observations can affect the behavior of these particles.

4. How does the HUP impact our understanding of the physical world?

The HUP has a significant impact on our understanding of the physical world because it suggests that at the quantum level, there are inherent limitations to what we can know about particles. It also highlights the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics, where we can only predict the likelihood of a particle's behavior, rather than knowing it with certainty.

5. Can the HUP be violated or overcome?

The HUP is a fundamental principle in quantum mechanics and has been extensively tested and confirmed through various experiments. It cannot be violated or overcome, but our understanding of it may evolve as we continue to study and learn more about the behavior of particles at the quantum level.

Back
Top