Integrating Complex Functions: Trapezoidal Rule Explained

  • Thread starter 2345qwert
  • Start date
In summary: However, in a complicated integral expression with many different variables and other terms, it may not be obvious which variable you are integrating with respect to. It is good practice and a good habit to learn to express the dx or d(whatever) now early in your calculus instruction so that it becomes automatic later on.
  • #1
2345qwert
12
0
"2 examples which you cannot integrate with your knowledge so far are ∫1/1+x2 and ∫√1+x3. You need to use the trapezoidal rule for this" This was written in my textbook and I really can't understand what it means! I mean why can't we integrate it in the normal basic way?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Well, which integration techniques have you studied? Have you studied integration by parts? Trigonometric substitutions?
 
  • #3
No, i haven't studied integration by parts or trigonometry substitutions yet. I have studied integration of exponentials and logarithms and simple functions.
 
  • #4
Your text is assuming that you haven't studied the integration techniques which you would need to find the antiderivatives of those two particular functions.
 
  • #5
2345qwert said:
"2 examples which you cannot integrate with your knowledge so far are ∫1/1+x2 and ∫√1+x3.
You really need to get up to speed on how to write mathematical expressions.
Exponents
I'm assuming that x2 and x3 mean x2 and x3, respectively. You can write exponents like these if you click the Go Advanced button just below the text entry pane. This opens the advanced menu across the top, which has an X2 button.

If this seems too complicated, you can use ^ to indicate a power such as x^2.

Parentheses
1/1 + x2 means (1/1) + x2, which is the same as 1 + x2. Since this is probably not what you meant, you need to add parentheses around the entire denominator, like this: 1/(1 + x2).

√1 + x3 means 1 + x3. To indicate that the square root includes the variable, use parentheses - √(1 + x3/SUP]).

Integrals
Neither of your integrals includes the differential, dx. At your stage of learning it might seem like a useless appendage, but trust me, it's there for a reason. If you get in the habit of omitting it, that practice will bite you in the butt later on.
 
  • #6
SteamKing said:
Your text is assuming that you haven't studied the integration techniques which you would need to find the antiderivatives of those two particular functions.

What are the integration techniques that I could use to find the antiderivatives of these functions, apart from the trapezoidal rule??
 
  • #7
Mark44 said:
You really need to get up to speed on how to write mathematical expressions.
Exponents
I'm assuming that x2 and x3 mean x2 and x3, respectively. You can write exponents like these if you click the Go Advanced button just below the text entry pane. This opens the advanced menu across the top, which has an X2 button.

If this seems too complicated, you can use ^ to indicate a power such as x^2.

Parentheses
1/1 + x2 means (1/1) + x2, which is the same as 1 + x2. Since this is probably not what you meant, you need to add parentheses around the entire denominator, like this: 1/(1 + x2).

√1 + x3 means 1 + x3. To indicate that the square root includes the variable, use parentheses - √(1 + x3/SUP]).

Integrals
Neither of your integrals includes the differential, dx. At your stage of learning it might seem like a useless appendage, but trust me, it's there for a reason. If you get in the habit of omitting it, that practice will bite you in the butt later on.


Thanks a lot for all your advice! But why is dx really important and what's the reason that it's there?
 
  • #8
2345qwert said:
What are the integration techniques that I could use to find the antiderivatives of these functions, apart from the trapezoidal rule??

The trapezoidal rule does not explicitly find the antiderivative of a given function; it provides a numerical means of evaluating a given definite integral.
 
  • #9
2345qwert said:
Thanks a lot for all your advice! But why is dx really important and what's the reason that it's there?

It is important to include the 'dx' in an integral expression to indicate w.r.t. which variable the integration takes place.

In the expressions you have been exposed to so far, it's probably pretty obvious which is the integration variable. However, in a complicated integral expression with many different variables and other terms, it may not be obvious which variable you are integrating with respect to. It is good practice and a good habit to learn to express the dx or d(whatever) now early in your calculus instruction so that it becomes automatic later on.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #10
2345qwert said:
What are the integration techniques that I could use to find the antiderivatives of these functions, apart from the trapezoidal rule??

Wait till you learn how to differentiate log, trig, and exponential functions.

But there are many functions that look "simple" but do not have "simple" antiderivatives. That is the case for your example of ##\int \sqrt{1+x^3}\, dx##. Integrals like that can be expressed in terms of "elliptic functions", but you won't learn about them in the standard "calculus sequence" of courses.

(If you really want to know the answer, go to http://integrals.wolfram.com/index.jsp?expr=sqrt[1+x^3]&random=false)
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #11
SteamKing said:
It is important to include the 'dx' in an integral expression to indicate w.r.t. which variable the integration takes place.

In the expressions you have been exposed to so far, it's probably pretty obvious which is the integration variable. However, in a complicated integral expression with many different variables and other terms, it may not be obvious which variable you are integrating with respect to. It is good practice and a good habit to learn to express the dx or d(whatever) now early in your calculus instruction so that it becomes automatic later on.

Okay! Thanks.
 
  • #12
AlephZero said:
Wait till you learn how to differentiate log, trig, and exponential functions.

But there are many functions that look "simple" but do not have "simple" antiderivatives. That is the case for your example of ##\int \sqrt{1+x^3}\, dx##. Integrals like that can be expressed in terms of "elliptic functions", but you won't learn about them in the standard "calculus sequence" of courses.

(If you really want to know the answer, go to http://integrals.wolfram.com/index.jsp?expr=sqrt[1+x^3]&random=false)

Wow! That is so complicated. But thanks for your help.
 

FAQ: Integrating Complex Functions: Trapezoidal Rule Explained

1. What is the Trapezoidal Rule and how is it used in integrating complex functions?

The Trapezoidal Rule is a numerical method for approximating the value of a definite integral. It works by approximating the area under the curve of a function by dividing it into trapezoids and summing their areas. This method is commonly used when it is difficult or impossible to find an exact solution to a complex integral.

2. How does the Trapezoidal Rule differ from other numerical integration methods?

The Trapezoidal Rule differs from other numerical integration methods, such as Simpson's Rule or the Midpoint Rule, in that it uses straight lines to approximate the curve of the function. This makes it a simpler method to implement, but it may not be as accurate as other methods for certain types of functions.

3. What are the advantages of using the Trapezoidal Rule?

One advantage of using the Trapezoidal Rule is that it is relatively easy to implement and does not require a lot of computational resources. It can also provide a good approximation for smooth functions with relatively few trapezoids, making it a quick and efficient method for obtaining an approximate solution to a complex integral.

4. Are there any limitations to using the Trapezoidal Rule?

Yes, there are some limitations to using the Trapezoidal Rule. It may not be as accurate as other numerical integration methods for certain types of functions, such as those with sharp corners or highly oscillatory behavior. Additionally, the accuracy of the approximation may decrease as the number of intervals used increases.

5. How can I improve the accuracy of the Trapezoidal Rule?

To improve the accuracy of the Trapezoidal Rule, you can use a smaller interval size, which means using more trapezoids to approximate the curve of the function. You can also use a more accurate method, such as Simpson's Rule or Gaussian Quadrature, if the function allows for it. Additionally, using a computer program or calculator to perform the calculations can reduce errors caused by human calculation.

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top