Integration under the integral sign

In summary, the conversation discusses a technique in Advanced Calculus called Integration Under the Integral Sign. This method involves replacing a hard integral with an equivalent one and then using Fubini's theorem to change the order of integration. This allows for the inner integral to be evaluated, resulting in a new integrand that is hopefully easier to integrate. The example given in the conversation uses this technique to evaluate an integral, showing how it can be a useful tool in solving difficult integrals.
  • #1
54stickers
29
0
Hello all who read,
I was reading along in the book Advanced Calculus by Frederick S. Woods today and came upon this technique. I played with it a little on some sample problems, but I still cannot figure out what it has any relation to.

My questions I guess are that,
(1) what does this method help to accomplish
(2) Do I have to differentiate the final result to have a "real" answer
(3) Why is the end result seem only related to the beginning by an integration operation

I may just be completely lost, and all these things be trivial. but any help would be great, thanks!

Here is a link to an example http://mathworld.wolfram.com/IntegrationUndertheIntegralSign.html"
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
(3)The problem is worked backwards (6) is the answer.
(2)This method could be used in different ways. As used in the link you do not have to differentiate the final result to have a "real" answer.
(1)This method could be used in different ways. As used in the link one reduces an integral to an easier one.

The idea of your example is
Problem: Compute an integral
1)The integral is hard now what?
Write the integral as two integrals iterated.
2)Now there are two integrals How did that help?
In some cases the integrals are easy in revese order and give the same answer
3)Reverse order of integrals (and justify to desired level of rigor).
This integral is easy
4)Do easy integral.
Done, rejoice.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
That makes sense, thanks.
 
  • #4
Sorry for bump and double post,

but I seem to still not understand after doing a few more examples, and trying to "Differentiate under the integral" of the integral in (6). That was quite futile for me.

In that link, is the Integral to be solved (6)?

If yes, how was the equation (2) deduced from (6)?

Thanks for the help!
 
  • #5
Perhaps the example page could be written more clearly. Evaluating the integral in (6) is the goal of that work. The trick in that example is to recognize that

[tex]\frac{x^b-x^a}{\ln x} = \int_a^b d\alpha x^\alpha.[/tex]

So, if you want to calculate

[tex]\int_0^1 dx~\frac{x^b-x^a}{\ln x},[/tex]
you can start by replacing with integrand with the equivalent integral. Then, you can interchange the order of the integrals (by Fubini's theorem, assuming it applies), and it turns out that the integral [itex]\int_0^1 dx~x^\alpha[/itex] is easier to do than the original integral, and is just equal to [itex]1/(\alpha+1)[/itex] (for [itex]\alpha \neq -1[/itex]).

So, you've reduced the original problem - evaulating the integral in (6) - to evaluating

[tex]\int_a^b d\alpha~\frac{1}{\alpha+1}.[/tex]

So, to summarize:

If you have a hard integral to do, but you recognize your integrand as being equivalent to another integral, you can replace the integrand with the equivalent integral, and then using Fubini's theorem you can change the order of integration. The inner integral is hopefully relatively easy to do, so you can perform that integral, and then hopefully you end up with a new integrand that's easier to integrate than the original integrand.
 
  • #6
That's quite a lot easier to follow!

Thanks!
 
Last edited:

FAQ: Integration under the integral sign

1. What is integration under the integral sign?

Integration under the integral sign is a technique used in calculus to evaluate integrals that cannot be solved using traditional methods. It involves treating the variable of integration as a constant and using the properties of integrals to simplify the expression.

2. When should integration under the integral sign be used?

Integration under the integral sign should be used when the integral cannot be solved using other techniques, such as substitution or integration by parts. It is also useful for calculating improper integrals or integrals with complicated limits.

3. What are the benefits of using integration under the integral sign?

The main benefit of using integration under the integral sign is that it allows for the evaluation of integrals that would otherwise be difficult or impossible to solve. It also provides a more efficient and elegant solution for certain types of integrals.

4. Are there any limitations to using integration under the integral sign?

While integration under the integral sign can be a powerful tool, it is not always applicable. It may not work for integrals with multiple variables or for integrals with highly complicated expressions.

5. How can one become proficient in using integration under the integral sign?

As with any mathematical technique, practice and familiarity are key to becoming proficient in using integration under the integral sign. It is important to have a strong understanding of basic calculus concepts and to work through various examples and problems to gain experience in applying the technique.

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Back
Top