Is [0, infinity) a closed set?

  • Thread starter michonamona
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Closed Set
In summary: You can keep inflating it, but eventually the balloon will burst.In summary, the closed set [0, +infinity) is a subset of the real numbers, but it's not a closed set in the usual sense.
  • #1
michonamona
122
0

Homework Statement


Is [0, infinity) a closed set?


Homework Equations


N/A


The Attempt at a Solution


It's easy to say that its not. But the solution in my textbook suggests otherwise. Why is this so?

Thanks!
M
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
If it isn't closed, you should be able to find a limit point that isn't in the interval, right? What point would that be?
 
  • #3
Is its complement open?
 
  • #4
LCKurtz:

Ok, I think I understand it for integers. Say, [1,5), where the limit point 5 is not in the interval. But what confuses me is infinity. How is it precisely defined with respect to actual numbers like integers?

vela:

What is its complement? R\[0, infinity)?

Hmm...
 
  • #5
Yes, that's the complement.

Just curious, what's the definition of a closed set that your class uses?
 
  • #6
If its complement is open, then I know that the interval is closed. But why? why is its complement open?

I appreciate you guys for not giving me the answers directly. I'm really trying hard to understand it.

M
 
  • #7
What's the definition of an open set?
 
  • #8
A set that contains only its interior points...

Its boundary is contained in its complement...
 
  • #9
The complement of [itex][0,\infty)[/itex] is [itex](-\infty,0)[/itex]. Let [itex]x\in(-\infty,0)[/itex]. Is there an open interval centered on x that's contained in [itex](-\infty,0)[/itex]?
 
  • #10
i think that it needs to be open on both sides.
if it were (0, infinity) it would be open. but since its its [0, infinity), it is a closed interval since you could make x = 0 and have a point, y, that lied to the left of 0, yet still within the Br(0) (ball of radius r about 0).
 
  • #11
michonamona said:
LCKurtz:

But what confuses me is infinity. How is it precisely defined with respect to actual numbers like integers?

Infinity is not part of the real numbers. [0,oo) is just a convenient alternative notation for [itex]x \ge 0[/itex]. You might think of the symbol as indicating the values of x are not bounded above.
 
  • #12
michonamona said:

Homework Statement


Is [0, infinity) a closed set?
Just FYI -- "closed" only makes sense relative to a space. The right question is
Is [0, +infinity) a closed subset of the reals​


But what confuses me is infinity.
It seems to be the habit to introduce it as a sort of "useful fiction". The set of nonnegative reals is quite interval-like, and it's useful to introduce a formal interval-like notation to write such things. Thus "[0, +infinity)".


However, if you go on, you should learn about the extended real numbers which are, IMO, a much better way to go about doing things. This number system has two additional numbers that the real numbers don't: -infinity and +infinity. And it turns out that every "useful fiction" that you learn in the introductory classes turns out to port to ordinary things in this more sophisticated approach, despite having the exact same notation. e.g. In the extended real numbers, [0,+infinity) is a perfectly ordinary interval, which consists of the nonnegative real numbers. (And the interval [0,+infinity] would consist of all nonnegative extended real numbers)
 
  • #13
It's like putting too much air in a balloon!
 

FAQ: Is [0, infinity) a closed set?

Is [0, ∞) a closed set?

Yes, [0, ∞) is a closed set. A set is considered closed if it contains all of its limit points. In this case, [0, ∞) includes its endpoint, which is also its limit point, making it a closed set.

What is the definition of a closed set?

A closed set is a set that contains all of its limit points. A limit point is a point that can be approximated by points in the set. In other words, every neighborhood of a limit point contains points within the set.

How is a closed set different from an open set?

A closed set contains all of its limit points, while an open set does not. In other words, there are points on the boundary of a closed set that are also considered part of the set, whereas points on the boundary of an open set are not included in the set.

Can a set be both open and closed?

Yes, a set can be both open and closed. This is known as a clopen set. An example of a clopen set is the set of all real numbers. It is open because any real number can be approximated by other real numbers, and it is closed because it contains all of its limit points.

Why is it important to understand closed sets in mathematics?

Understanding closed sets is important in mathematics because it helps us define and analyze different types of spaces, such as topological spaces. Closed sets also play a crucial role in the concept of continuity, which is fundamental in many areas of mathematics, including calculus and analysis.

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
4K
Back
Top