Is it rude/ambitious to send your paper to people?

  • Thread starter Pythagorean
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Paper
In summary, it is acceptable to send a paper (or link) to someone who may potentially be interested in your research and could cite it in the future as long as it is not unsolicited, done in a mass mailing, or for the sole purpose of gaining citations. It is important to approach it as a means for intellectual discussion and not just a request for a citation. Personal contact and prior conversations can also make it more acceptable.
  • #1
Pythagorean
Gold Member
4,409
320
Obviously the greedy goal is to increase your research impact, but is it considered rude or over-ambitious to send a paper you published (or rather, a link to it, to avoid copyright issues) to people who might potentially be interested in your research (and might possibly cite it in the future)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Pythagorean said:
Obviously the greedy goal is to increase your research impact, but is it considered rude or over-ambitious to send a paper you published (or rather, a link to it, to avoid copyright issues) to people who might potentially be interested in your research (and might possibly cite it in the future)?

If it is unsolicited, and it is someone you do not know well, then the answer is YES.

It also doesn't reflect well on you, because you are desperate for citation. That is never a good sign.

Zz.
 
  • #3
No, as long as you don't do it all the time. It should be a personal email, and not a mass mailing. You should send the paper and not the link, since the recipient is unlikely to want to pay to read your paper.
 
  • #4
ZapperZ said:
If it is unsolicited, and it is someone you do not know well, then the answer is YES.

It also doesn't reflect well on you, because you are desperate for citation. That is never a good sign.

Zz.

What if it's someone you've specifically cited and your research supports some of their conclusions?
 
  • #5
Pythagorean said:
What if it's someone you've specifically cited and your research supports some of their conclusions?

Then contact this person with the intention that you are interested in that person's work, and do it as a means for an intellectual discussion, rather than "hey, here's my paper!"

I've contact several people, and I've been contacted a lot by people either having questions, or interested in my opinion of certain things. I lose all interest if the email only contains "Hi, we think you might be interested in reading our paper." I consider that as spam. If they can't be bothered to explain why, and if all they want from me is for me to cite their paper, then my finger reaches for the delete button very quickly.

Zz.
 
  • #6
That's a reasonable expectation. I certainly planned on introducing myself and the paper with discussion. And as atty recommended, it's really a very personal approach, I am imagining, not a mass e-mailing.

Prior to even starting the paper, I'd already contacted one of the people I have in mind previously for the purpose of discussion and he seemed very supportive of the research I was doing (he an emeritus, me a grad student).

One of the main issues is that I'm a mathematical modeller, and these are experimental biologists... so I worry that my papers are outside their search scope even though it's not outside their research scope.
 
  • #7
Pythagorean said:
One of the main issues is that I'm a mathematical modeller, and these are experimental biologists... so I worry that my papers are outside their search scope even though it's not outside their research scope.

But of course, you won't tell them that. They'll have to be reading this thread to find out, right?
 
  • #8
I think it all depends on the delivery.

If you are at least potentially interested in some kind of collaboration or extended discussion, then I would think it's fine. Given that you've already had a conversation with one of them, I don't see an issue with forwarding a copy of the paper just to let him or her know that this was where your work has gone.
 

FAQ: Is it rude/ambitious to send your paper to people?

Is it considered rude to send my paper to people without their permission?

No, it is not considered rude as long as you are sending it to individuals who may be interested in your research or have requested to see it. However, it is always polite to ask for permission before sending your paper to someone.

Can I send my paper to multiple people at once?

Yes, you can send your paper to multiple people at once, especially if they are all in the same field of study or have expressed interest in your research. This can help increase the visibility and impact of your work.

Is it considered ambitious to send my paper to well-known researchers or professors?

No, it is not considered ambitious. In fact, it is a good idea to send your paper to well-known researchers or professors who may have valuable feedback or may be interested in collaborating with you. However, make sure to tailor your approach and be respectful of their time and expertise.

Should I include a personal message when sending my paper to people?

It is not necessary to include a personal message, but it can be a nice gesture to briefly introduce yourself and explain why you are sending them your paper. This can also help make a more personal connection with the recipient.

Is it appropriate to send my paper to someone who has rejected my work in the past?

It is generally not appropriate to send your paper to someone who has rejected your work in the past, unless they have specifically requested to see your revised paper. It is important to respect their decision and not persistently send your paper to them.

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
962
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
16
Views
2K
Back
Top