Is light really light outside the human brain?

In summary, the conversation discusses the idea that color and brightness are subjective sensations created by the brain's interpretation of light. It suggests that the entire universe may be black outside of the human mind and questions the validity of using instruments to understand the universe. The concept of solipism is mentioned and dismissed as being unproductive in understanding the universe.
  • #1
zeromodz
246
0
We know that color is a sensation in the brain from interpreting different wavelengths of light. Therefore, color does not actually exist in the real external universe. Why not take it a step further and say that the sensation of brightness is a human concept. Not that actual magnitude of brightness, but the notion of interpreting brightness just as we interpret colors.

What if the entire universe is completely black outside the human mind (Or any organism's mind), and light is just a wave with different frequencies that in reality, doesn't reveal anything? What do you think?
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
zeromodz said:
g
What if the entire universe is completely black outside the human mind (Or any organism's mind), and light is just a wave with different frequencies that in reality, doesn't reveal anything? What do you think?

Well, it seems that "black" is a reasonable description if there is no mind or eye to perceive light from sources in the universe. But how do you blend instruments such as the HST into your thinking about this? Should we discount whatever it reveals to us? I'm confused...

OF
 
  • #3
This line of reasoning is called solipism, it's almost 2000 years old, and it is not physics, it is philosophy. (And bad philosophy at that, because it's sterile - it doesn't teach us much that is useful).
 

FAQ: Is light really light outside the human brain?

What exactly is light?

Light is a form of electromagnetic radiation that is visible to the human eye. It is made up of tiny particles called photons that travel in waves.

How does light travel outside of the human brain?

Light travels through space in a straight line unless it is reflected or refracted by an object. Outside of the human brain, light travels through the air or other transparent materials such as water or glass.

Is light affected by gravity outside of the human brain?

Yes, light is affected by gravity outside of the human brain. This was proven by Albert Einstein's theory of general relativity, which states that gravity can bend the path of light.

Can light be seen in a vacuum?

No, light cannot be seen in a vacuum because there are no particles for the light to bounce off of. This is why we cannot see stars or other objects in space when we look at them with our naked eye.

How does the human brain perceive light?

The human brain perceives light through specialized cells in the retina called photoreceptors. These cells convert light into electrical signals that are then sent to the brain for interpretation, allowing us to see the world around us.

Back
Top