Is memorization bad or good in this case? Is it even necessary?

  • Thread starter Domnu
  • Start date
  • Tags
    even
In summary, the conversation discusses the introduction of Hermitian polynomials in the study of quantum mechanics and the complexity of 3D quantum mechanics, which involves differential equations with solutions such as spherical harmonics and associated Legendre, Bessel, and Neumann functions. It also touches on the approach to learning these mathematical concepts in a quantum mechanics course.
  • #1
Domnu
178
0
When (self)learning quantum mechanics, I was introduced to Hermitian polynomials when learning about harmonic oscillators. This was pretty simple to remember, but then, today, when I first started reading about 3D quantum mechanics (when the Schroedinger equation has now become spherical), I am being attacked by differential equations which have *very* strange solutions... some of them include the spherical harmonics, associated Legendre functions (with Legendre polynomials), Bessel spherical functions, and Neumann spherical functions.

In a quantum mechanics undergraduate course, are such formulae provided (to avoid memorization)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
When I took quantum mechanics, I did not have to know "Legendre functions (with Legendre polynomials), Bessel spherical functions, and Neumann spherical functions" too thoroughly. As I recall, I was just learning Bessel, Neumann, and Legendre functions.

The answer might depend on your learning style. I learn things from the top down. I get the big picture first, and then dig down into the finer (and more finer) details. If it were me I would just focus on the quantum mechanics and learn what ever mathematical details it required.
 

FAQ: Is memorization bad or good in this case? Is it even necessary?

Is memorization good or bad for learning?

The answer to this question is not straightforward. Memorization can be beneficial for learning certain information, such as basic facts and vocabulary. However, it can also hinder deeper understanding and critical thinking if relied upon too heavily.

Is memorization necessary for success?

Success can be achieved through a variety of methods, and memorization is not always necessary. While it may be helpful in certain situations, other skills such as problem-solving and creativity are also important for success.

How does memorization affect the brain?

Memorization can strengthen neural connections and improve memory recall. However, it can also lead to a shallow understanding of a topic and limit the brain's ability to make connections and think critically.

Can memorization be harmful?

Memorization itself is not harmful, but relying solely on memorization can limit a person's ability to think critically and problem-solve. It can also lead to stress and pressure to constantly remember information perfectly.

How can memorization be used effectively?

Memorization can be useful when combined with other learning strategies, such as active recall and spaced repetition. It is also important to balance memorization with deeper understanding and critical thinking to truly master a subject.

Back
Top