Is Pluto Really Not a Planet Anymore?

In summary: Ceres to be considered a planet, it's not clear that it has. It's been in the asteroid belt for quite some time now and I don't think it would be fair to call it a planet just because it's there.In summary, I don't think the decision was fair to Pluto. The fact that it wasn't provided with a lawyer meant that it didn't have a fair chance to defend itself, and it wasn't given a chance to be upgraded to a dwarf planet. I think we should make a positive spin on this and focus on the new definition of planet that includes dwarf planets.
  • #36
Jimmy Snyder said:
It's a red herring. Neither red, nor herring.

Where?! *gets frying pan and oil*
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #37
Chi Meson said:
Sedna? Haumea?

Quaoar!

How can you deny a dwarfie named Quaoar?!

True...but Quaoar only has a cool name, Sedna has a pretty orbit and Haumea is beautifully oval:biggrin:
kuiper.jpg

look at that sexy thing!:-p
 
  • #39
Chi Meson said:
Here's a nice composite of the largest TNOs:
I hadn't realized until now that the Earth is trans-Neptunian.
 
  • #40
HeLiXe said:
kuiper.jpg

look at that sexy thing!:-p

I think I am too old. It doesn't look sexy to me.
 
  • #41
Borek said:
I think I am too old. It doesn't look sexy to me.
You're not too old, you're just spoiled by Marzena.
 
  • #42
Jimmy Snyder said:
I hadn't realized until now that the Earth is trans-Neptunian.

And the largest!
 
  • #43
Borek said:
This is ridiculous. How can a dog be a planet.

Well, if you feed it enough...
 
  • #44
Borek said:
I think I am too old. It doesn't look sexy to me.
Perhaps you're more of a spherical guy?
 
  • #46
HeLiXe said:
True...but Quaoar only has a cool name, Sedna has a pretty orbit and Haumea is beautifully oval:biggrin:
kuiper.jpg

look at that sexy thing!:-p
It looks like an ostrich egg.
 
  • #47
Pluto is no longer a planet?

What's next: you going to tell me that Cruithne is no longer our moon?
 
  • #48
Astronuc said:
It looks like an ostrich egg.
>_> Now what am I supposed to say...if I agree, everyone will think I find ostrich eggs sexy!
Gokul43201 said:
What's next: you going to tell me that Cruithne is no longer our moon?

NO WAY! I never knew about this! Thanks Gokul, this completely blew my mind tonight.
 
Back
Top