Is the Fizeau-Type Experiment Valid for Measuring the One-Way Speed of Light?

  • I
  • Thread starter lightarrow
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Experiment
In summary, the paper presents a flawed experiment that uses an anisotropic one-way speed of light. The authors neglect to take into account the effect of the anisotropy on the experiment, and the paper has been critiqued for this error in the past.
  • #1
lightarrow
1,968
63
TL;DR Summary
A Fizeau-type experiment were they claim to be able to measure the one-way speed of light.
Can't see how in this experiment they claim to be able to measure the one-way speed of light:

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/50908639_To_Re-Consider_the_One-Way_Speed_of_Light_UsingFizeau-Type-Coupled-Slotted-Disks

Can you help me to debunk it?

--
lightarrow
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
They seem to have neglected the fact that an anisotropic one-way speed of light will result in a stress-free twisting of the apparatus. This stress-free twisting happens in ordinary relativity in reference frames where the apparatus is translating. But when using anisotropic one-way speed of light then it will happen also in reference frames where the apparatus is not translating, depending on its orientation with respect to the light speed anisotropy.

The authors should have analyzed their results using Reichenbach’s ##\epsilon## or some other similar framework which explicitly supports an anisotropic one way speed of light. Then they could see that their measured results are independent of the ##\epsilon## anisotropy parameter.

Plus, it is researchgate, so does it really need to be debunked anyway?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes vanhees71 and Ibix
  • #3
You can easily measure the one-way speed of light. What you can't do is measure it in an assumption-free way.

I haven't dug much into their paper (a ten year old paper that hasn't found a publisher is not a great sign) but my skim read reached the same conclusion Dale did. The wheels are effectively clocks and are Einstein synchronised in their rest frame. In any other frame or under any other synchronisation convention the rod connecting them is twisted and they are desynchronised.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71 and Dale
  • #4
Incidentally, Marinov (cited in the paper) is criticised in the Experimental Basis of SR FAQ (linked from a sticky thread in this very forum) for exactly this error. These guys seem to be simply repeating it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes vanhees71
  • #5
lightarrow said:
Can you help me to debunk it?
We usually do not allow threads just for debunking crackpottery - if we did , there wouldn't be room for anything else.

We have made an exception for this one as the misunderstanding is common and easily explained. However, now that it has attracted reasonably complete and accurate explanations we can close it. As with all thread closures, if you believe that it is premature and have more to say, you can ask any mentor to reopen it for your contribution.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes berkeman, vanhees71 and Dale

FAQ: Is the Fizeau-Type Experiment Valid for Measuring the One-Way Speed of Light?

What is a Fizeau-type experiment?

A Fizeau-type experiment is a scientific experiment designed to measure the speed of light. It was first performed by French physicist Hippolyte Fizeau in 1849.

How does a Fizeau-type experiment work?

In a Fizeau-type experiment, a beam of light is split into two parts and sent through two different paths. One path is left open, while the other is partially blocked by a rotating wheel. The light from both paths is then recombined and observed through a telescope. By measuring the interference patterns of the light, the speed of light can be calculated.

What is the significance of a Fizeau-type experiment?

The Fizeau-type experiment is significant because it was one of the first experiments to accurately measure the speed of light. It also provided evidence for the wave theory of light, as the interference patterns observed were consistent with the idea of light being a wave.

What are some modern applications of the Fizeau-type experiment?

The Fizeau-type experiment is still used in modern times to measure the speed of light with even greater accuracy. It is also used in the development and calibration of high-speed cameras, as well as in the study of optical fibers and their transmission of light.

Are there any limitations to the Fizeau-type experiment?

One limitation of the Fizeau-type experiment is that it assumes the speed of light is constant in a vacuum. This may not be the case in all situations, such as in the presence of strong gravitational fields. Additionally, the accuracy of the experiment can be affected by external factors such as temperature and air pressure.

Back
Top