Is this egg-laying or something else?

In summary, the article explores the differences between egg-laying and other reproductive strategies in animals, examining various species' reproductive behaviors and the evolutionary advantages of each method. It highlights the biological processes involved in egg development and the environmental factors influencing reproductive choices, ultimately questioning traditional categorizations of reproductive methods.
  • #1
somegrue
12
7
TL;DR Summary
Some sort of bee is crawling into holes in wooden furniture and eventually plugging them. What's going on? (With pictures.)
My apartment's balcony door is wide open more often than not. This time of year, that tends to mean that insects keep flying in and out. Most of them, or at least most of the ones that are large and/or loud enough for me to notice, are bee and wasp types. They behave quite differently from the bees and wasps I get later in the year - most strikingly, they totally ignore food, even when it's readily accessible, and instead seem to be interested in wood and fabric. My interpretation is that this is to do with nest-building or the like. A couple of years ago, one of them did indeed start building a nest inside the apartment, suspended below a wooden board. Fortunately, the nest was right in the open and I noticed and removed it before she got very far. That was a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper_wasp, I think.

Some of the (furry) bee types seem to be particularly attracted to holes in wood, like those in the uprights of Lundia or Ikea's Ivar shelf systems. They carefully look for holes, investigate them, and if they decide they like them, start a routine alternating between doing something inside the hole and doing something else outside the apartment. Their flight paths get quite efficient, directly from the door to the hole, then directly back to the door, none of that buzzing around the room and across windows that they start with. They keep at this for hours and days on end, many times per hour. The end result is a plugged hole.

Pictures:

(The hole above the one in progress is already plugged. Sorry the quality isn't better, there's something in the way that's real tricky to move, so the camera is at a bit of an awkward angle and it's too dark to do without the flash.)

My uneducated guess is that behind the plug, there's an egg and some food, and that gathering that supply, and whatever the plug is made of, is why they need to do all that flying back and forth.

Does that seem likely? If so, does that mean that these are non-social bees of some sort - or maybe not bees at all, despite the furriness? (I'm in Germany, in case that narrows it down.) If not, what might be going on instead?

Last but nowhere near least, Is there any practical reason to worry about and so try and stop them doing this, like there very clearly was for the paper wasp nest?

Thanks for any insights! :)
 
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #2
Probably a nesting site.
Could be a solitary bee or wasp.
Could also be ants. Termites unlikely.
your local agricultural extension service might help with ID'ing the insect. (Maybe Germany doesn't have these, but there is probably something similar.)
Probably not something to worry about unless the holes in the wood are a problem.
 
  • Like
Likes somegrue
  • #3
Carpenter bees maybe?

1712956755336.png

https://thedailypest.vikingpest.com/carpenter-bee-faq
 
  • Like
Likes Rive, somegrue and BillTre
  • #4
Sounds like your call on the solitary bee is right on. There’s a couple species that I know of right off the bat that demonstrate this kind of behavior, namely carpenter bees and leafcutter bees. I only know of the latter by reputation and documentaries, but I know carpenter bees well enough from my time growing up in California. Those were some mighty big bees, and would actively chew a tunnel into the crossmembers of the grape arbor in the backyard every spring. If you were quiet, you could actually hear them chewing. I’m not entirely sure that’s what you have, but it’s similar.

I second the suggestion of the ag extension, or perhaps a local nature center/museum, for assistance in identifying the bee.

If you’re worried about the bees causing problems, put out a bunch of tubes in the yard or surrounding area, making sure they’ve of similar size to the ones they seem to like, and hopefully the bees will accept the offering and leave your furniture alone.
 
  • Like
Likes somegrue, BillTre and berkeman
  • #5
Flyboy said:
put out a bunch of tubes in the yard or surrounding area, making sure they’ve of similar size to the ones they seem to like, and hopefully the bees will accept the offering and leave your furniture alone.
My wife did that last year and she enjoyed watching the carpenter bees do their thing. :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes somegrue and BillTre
  • #6
I remember something in the directions that came with my wife's carpenter bee tunnel house that specified which way the open tube ends should face. I did a quick search and it looks like they should face the morning Sun...

1712960443385.png
 
  • Like
Likes somegrue and BillTre
  • #7
berkeman said:
I remember something in the directions that came with my wife's carpenter bee tunnel house that specified which way the open tube ends should face. I did a quick search and it looks like they should face the morning Sun...
Wake up little bees, wake up!
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Likes somegrue and berkeman
  • #8
Flyboy said:
Sounds like your call on the solitary bee is right on. There’s a couple species that I know of right off the bat that demonstrate this kind of behavior, namely carpenter bees and leafcutter bees. I only know of the latter by reputation and documentaries, but I know carpenter bees well enough from my time growing up in California. Those were some mighty big bees, and would actively chew a tunnel into the crossmembers of the grape arbor in the backyard every spring. If you were quiet, you could actually hear them chewing. I’m not entirely sure that’s what you have, but it’s similar.
Thanks!

The de.wikipedia articles mention that the two have very different hatching behaviours: Carpenters grow quickly, emerge the same spring, are active during summer and autumn, and then hibernate before laying eggs themselves the next spring. Leafcutters grow so slowly that they hibernate before emerging the next spring, so they have to mate and lay eggs as soon as they become active.

Yep, I did hear something while I was taking the pictures! Just couldn't quite tell if it was the bee, and whether it was chewing or rustling or whatever...

One of the articles mentions that carpenters sometimes return to their old nests, both for shelter and to re-use them the next year, and that those multi-generational nests may then become more of a cause for concern. For the time being, keeping an eye on things should be all that's needful. :)
 
  • Like
Likes BillTre and berkeman
  • #9
Flyboy said:
If you’re worried about the bees causing problems, put out a bunch of tubes in the yard or surrounding area, making sure they’ve of similar size to the ones they seem to like, and hopefully the bees will accept the offering and leave your furniture alone.
This kind also works just fine:
odu1.jpg


Ps.: I hope this works: some tips about the making, and some pictures about the internal workings of the nesting site at the end...
 
  • Like
Likes BillTre, berkeman and somegrue
  • #10
Rive said:
This kind also works just fine:
View attachment 343288

Ps.: I hope this works: some tips about the making, and some pictures about the internal workings of the nesting site at the end...
Cheers! I thought "insect hotel!" as soon as I saw your picture, and that Wikipedia article mentions the more specialized https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bee_hotel as well. Silly of me not to have the connection right away or at least from the previous posts here, really!

berkeman said:
I remember something in the directions that came with my wife's carpenter bee tunnel house that specified which way the open tube ends should face. I did a quick search and it looks like they should face the morning Sun...
From said article:
en.wikipedia said:
Bees, unlike wasps, favour hotels that receive direct (especially morning) sunlight, and that are closer to the ground. Bee hotels located on multi-storey building rooftops and in shaded areas are more likely to attract wasps.
 
  • Like
Likes BillTre and berkeman

FAQ: Is this egg-laying or something else?

What is the difference between egg-laying and live birth?

Egg-laying, or oviparity, involves the female organism laying eggs that develop outside her body, while live birth, or viviparity, involves the development of embryos inside the female's body until they are ready to be born. Some species, such as reptiles and birds, are oviparous, while mammals, including humans, are typically viviparous.

How can I tell if an animal is egg-laying?

To determine if an animal is egg-laying, observe its reproductive behavior. Egg-laying species typically have a nesting behavior, where they create a safe environment for their eggs. Additionally, you can look for physical characteristics such as the presence of a cloaca, which is common in birds, reptiles, and amphibians.

Are all reptiles egg-layers?

No, not all reptiles are egg-layers. While many reptiles, such as most turtles and snakes, lay eggs, some species, like certain lizards and snakes, give birth to live young. This reproductive strategy can vary widely even within the same family of reptiles.

What are some examples of egg-laying animals?

Examples of egg-laying animals include birds, most reptiles, amphibians, and fish. Specific examples are chickens, turtles, frogs, and salmon. Each of these groups has adapted to laying eggs in different environments, whether on land, in water, or in nests.

Can egg-laying animals exhibit parental care?

Yes, many egg-laying animals exhibit varying degrees of parental care. For instance, some bird species incubate their eggs and feed their chicks after they hatch. Similarly, certain reptiles, like crocodiles, will protect their nests and assist their young in reaching the water after hatching.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
3K
Replies
30
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
480
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
21
Views
4K
Back
Top