Is this statement correct with the right reasoning?

In summary, the conversation discusses the impact of replacing a capacitor with a larger one in a battery-bulb-capacitor circuit. The larger capacitor allows for more charge to accumulate on the plates, resulting in a longer time for the bulb to stay on. Mathematically, this can be represented by the equation (Q/A)/2εo, where A is the area of the capacitor and Q is the charge. The conversation also highlights the complexity of the fringe field in a capacitor and the importance of providing a circuit diagram for clear understanding.
  • #1
yeezyseason3
16
0
Assume you have a simple battery-bulb-capacitor circuit. If you replace the capacitor with one that has twice the area as the old capacitor, the bulb will stay on longer because there has to be more charge to accumulate on the plates of the capacitor to zero out the net electric field. Mathematically speaking in (Q/A)/2εo (equation of the fringe field of a capacitor) if A increases, Q has to also to get a net fringe equivalent to the electric field inside the wire. Since current stays the same and more charge has to accumulate, it takes longer.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
yeezyseason3 said:
Assume you have a simple battery-bulb-capacitor circuit.

depending on how it is wired, the bulb isn't likely to work
Do you understand what a capacitor is and how it works ?

show a circuit for your idea so we can confirm what you are talking about
Dave
 
  • #3
yeezyseason3 said:
Since current stays the same and more charge has to accumulate, it takes longer.
I think what you wrote was generally good, but it is a little hard to claim "current stays the same" in a situation like this where the current changes over time. I would say instead that the time constant is RC, since C is double, then RC is also double, and everything takes twice as long.
 
  • #4
Besides what was already said, the fringe field is not described by that simple formula, it is quite complicated and depends on position.
The formula may be OK for points very far from the edges of the capacitor, so exactly what the fringe field is not. :)
 
  • #5
yeezyseason3 said:
Assume you have a simple battery-bulb-capacitor circuit.
A "simple" circuit still needs to be described - even when there are only three components. A diagram usually makes sure that everyone understands your question.
 
  • Like
Likes davenn

Related to Is this statement correct with the right reasoning?

1. Is the statement correct?

The answer to this question depends on the statement in question. In order to determine if a statement is correct, one must analyze its logic and evidence. Without this information, it is impossible to definitively say if a statement is correct or not.

2. What is the right reasoning behind this statement?

The reasoning behind a statement can vary greatly, depending on the subject matter and context. It is important to consider the logic and evidence that supports a statement in order to understand its reasoning.

3. How can I determine if the reasoning behind a statement is valid?

To determine if the reasoning behind a statement is valid, one must carefully examine the evidence and the logic used to support the statement. This involves critically analyzing the information presented and evaluating its credibility.

4. Are there any common fallacies to watch out for when evaluating the reasoning behind a statement?

Yes, there are several common fallacies that can occur in reasoning, such as circular reasoning, appeal to authority, and false cause. It is important to be aware of these fallacies and to critically evaluate the reasoning behind a statement to avoid being misled.

5. Can a statement be correct even if the reasoning behind it is flawed?

No, a statement cannot be considered completely correct if the reasoning behind it is flawed. While a statement may have some elements of truth, if the reasoning behind it is flawed, the overall statement cannot be considered fully correct.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
18
Views
2K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
694
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
656
Replies
103
Views
5K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
999
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
606
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
11
Views
2K
Back
Top