- #1
- 5,617
- 2,937
That kind of resolution would be very difficult to achieve, and I believe it is well beyond the accuracy of any commercially available instrument. To achieve anywhere near this kind of precision would be quite painstaking. I can see where no one has attempted to repeat it to that level of accuracy. (Edit note: These initial comments may be in error. See post 5, etc.). With a commercially available instrument, one would typically measure something like ##\lambda= 1215.3 ## angstroms at first order, and you can get additional precision by doing it at fifth order. In general, the accuracy would be limited to the accuracy of the other spectral lines that you use as a standard. ## \\ ## In the Herzberg measurement, he most likely measured it from first principles=i.e. measuring ## \sin{\theta_i} ## and ## \sin{\theta_r} ##, rather than using other spectral lines. Alternatively, he could have calibrated his spectrometer with another source, such as the iron lines, that are commonly used as a wavelength standard. I don't have access to any iron calibration standard handbook at present, but if I remember correctly, the precision is perhaps ##+/- .001 ## angstroms. @neilparker62 Perhaps you could try to find some info on the currently available precision of these standards.neilparker62 said:Thanks - read your article with interest albeit perhaps needing to do some careful study to properly understand all the equations.
In the Insights article I wrote on the Deuterium Lyman Alpha line, the claimed resolution with a "3 metre vacuum grating spectrograph in fifth order" was:
$$L_\alpha(D)=1215.3378\pm0.00025 Å$$
Is this level of resolution achievable with a modern diffraction grating spectrometer and if so why has there been no attempt to repeat Herzberg's measurement (at least not as far as I can make out anyway) ?
Re-Optimized Energy Levels and Ritz Wavelengths of ##^{ 198}##Hg I,Charles Link said:@neilparker62 Perhaps you could try to find some info on the currently available precision of these standards.
Frequency measurement and resolution at RF will take you easily to One part in 1011. Pretty damn good eh?Charles Link said:they are using an FTS=Fourier transform spectrometer, which uses a Michelson interferometer based system. In any case, the resolution is quite phenomenal.
It appears that the FTS Michelson interferometer may have the best (absolute) resolution/precision for determining the wavelength of isolated and very bright and narrow spectral lines, to be used as wavelength calibration standards. Once these "standard" wavelengths are determined, a diffraction grating spectrometer can be used to accurately measure the wavelengths of other sources, including those that have many spectral lines. ## \\ ## With a diffraction grating spectrometer, when working from first principles, (i.e. working with ##d, \theta_i ##, and ## \theta_r ##, and computing ## \lambda=\frac{d(\sin{\theta_i}+\sin{\theta_r})}{m} ##), the highest (absolute) precision that can be readily achieved may be on the order of +/- .001 angstroms. Using wavelength calibration standards from an FTS, relative precision for the diffraction grating instruments can then be taken to the diffraction limit of resolution, which may be a couple orders of magnitude smaller.sophiecentaur said:Frequency measurement and resolution at RF will take you easily to One part in 1011. Pretty damn good eh?
A diffraction grating spectrometer is a scientific instrument used to analyze the properties of light. It consists of a grating, a device with a series of closely spaced parallel lines, which separates light into its component wavelengths. This allows scientists to measure the intensity and wavelength of light, which can provide valuable information about the composition and structure of materials.
A diffraction grating spectrometer works by using the principle of diffraction, which is the bending of light as it passes through a narrow slit or closely spaced lines. The grating in the spectrometer acts as a diffraction grating, separating the different wavelengths of light. The light then passes through a slit and is focused onto a detector, which measures the intensity of light at each wavelength.
A diffraction grating spectrometer has a wide range of applications in various fields of science, including astronomy, chemistry, and physics. It is commonly used to study the properties of light emitted by stars and other celestial bodies, as well as to analyze the composition of materials in chemistry experiments. It is also used in the development of optical instruments and in the study of atomic and molecular structures.
To use a diffraction grating spectrometer, you first need to set up the instrument by aligning the grating, slit, and detector. Then, you can place the sample or light source in front of the slit and adjust the instrument to select the desired wavelength range. The detector will then measure the intensity of light at each wavelength, which can be recorded and analyzed to gather information about the sample or light source.
A diffraction grating spectrometer offers several advantages over other methods of light analysis. It is highly accurate and precise, allowing for the measurement of even small changes in light intensity. It also has a wide range of wavelength coverage, making it suitable for a variety of applications. Additionally, it is a non-destructive technique, meaning the sample or light source is not altered or damaged during the analysis process.