Loop Coil Comparison: Hollow Tubing vs. Solid Wire

In summary, the main difference between hollow tubing and solid wire in a loop coil is their structure. While both types can effectively conduct electricity, solid wire is generally considered to have better conductivity and durability. However, hollow tubing is easier to manipulate and shape due to its flexibility. Both have their own advantages and disadvantages, with hollow tubing being lighter and easier to manipulate but potentially having lower conductivity and durability, while solid wire may have better conductivity and durability but may be more difficult to manipulate.
  • #1
japam
39
0
Is the same inductance formula valid for a coil made of hollow tubbing that for a solid wire made , with both having the same width?,
and supposing that a high frequency current flows through it
whats the skin effect influence on the result
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
Is this homework? What is the application? What are the physical dimensions, and what is the frequency range of interest?
 

FAQ: Loop Coil Comparison: Hollow Tubing vs. Solid Wire

1. What is the difference between hollow tubing and solid wire in a loop coil?

The main difference between hollow tubing and solid wire in a loop coil is their structure. Hollow tubing has a hollow center, while solid wire is filled with material throughout its entire diameter. This means that hollow tubing has a larger internal space and thinner walls compared to solid wire.

2. Which type of loop coil is better for conducting electricity?

Both hollow tubing and solid wire can effectively conduct electricity. However, solid wire is generally considered to have better conductivity due to its more compact structure and larger surface area for electrons to flow through.

3. Is there a difference in durability between hollow tubing and solid wire loop coils?

In terms of durability, solid wire is typically considered to be more durable than hollow tubing. This is because solid wire has a more solid and compact structure, making it less prone to bending or breaking compared to hollow tubing.

4. Which type of loop coil is easier to manipulate and shape?

Hollow tubing is generally easier to manipulate and shape compared to solid wire. This is because hollow tubing is more flexible and can be bent or molded into different shapes without breaking or deforming.

5. Are there any advantages or disadvantages of using hollow tubing or solid wire in a loop coil?

Both hollow tubing and solid wire have their own advantages and disadvantages in a loop coil. Hollow tubing has a larger internal space, making it lighter and easier to manipulate, but it may have lower conductivity and durability. On the other hand, solid wire may have better conductivity and durability, but it may be more difficult to manipulate due to its compact structure.

Similar threads

Back
Top