Measuring Low Resistance: Why Meter Bridge is the Preferred Choice

In summary, the meter bridge is chosen over the post office box for measuring low resistance because it allows for a wider measurement range, makes better use of the meter sensitivity, and has a sensitive method for measuring low resistances. The post office box, which is a Wheatstone bridge circuit, is limited in its measurement range and is primarily used for finding short circuits.
  • #1
phymath7
48
4
TL;DR Summary
Why post office box can't be used to measure high or low resistance?
Why meter bridge is chosen over post office box to measure low resistance?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
What is "post office box" (or "vox")?
 
  • #4
Ah. According to the Wikipedia article the Post Office Box (origin UK) is in fact a Wheatstone bridge circuit.
 
  • #5
phymath7 said:
TL;DR Summary: Why post office box can't be used to measure high or low resistance?

Why meter bridge is chosen over post office box to measure low resistance?
Who says it can't be used to measure high or low resistance ?
The post office box was two arms of a Wheatstone bridge.
It was used to find short circuits, not open breaks in the line.
 
  • Like
Likes Tom.G
  • #6
phymath7 said:
TL;DR Summary: Why post office box can't be used to measure high or low resistance?

Why meter bridge is chosen over post office box to measure low resistance?
I think the measurement range will be limited by the available ratio arms and standard resistances. In addition, a bridge does not make best use of the meter sensitivity because it is shunted by the bridge components. There is a sensitive method for low resistances where we first pass a current through the meter to give full scale deflection and then measure the drop in reading when the meter is shunted by the unknown low resistance.
(Sorry, I recently disposed of my copy of "Telephony", by Herbert and Proctor, which would have given the definitive answer).
 

FAQ: Measuring Low Resistance: Why Meter Bridge is the Preferred Choice

What is a meter bridge and how does it work?

A meter bridge, also known as a Wheatstone Bridge, is an instrument used to measure an unknown electrical resistance by balancing two legs of a bridge circuit. It consists of a one-meter-long wire of uniform cross-section, a galvanometer, a known resistor, and a jockey to make contact at different points on the wire. By adjusting the position of the jockey, the bridge can be balanced, and the unknown resistance can be calculated using the known values and the principles of the Wheatstone Bridge.

Why is a meter bridge preferred for measuring low resistance?

A meter bridge is preferred for measuring low resistance because it provides high accuracy and precision. The long wire used in the meter bridge allows for fine adjustments, which leads to more accurate determination of the balance point. Additionally, the meter bridge minimizes errors due to contact resistance and lead resistance, which are significant factors when measuring low resistances.

What are the advantages of using a meter bridge over other methods?

Using a meter bridge has several advantages: it offers high precision and accuracy, it is relatively simple and inexpensive to set up, and it allows for direct measurement of resistance without needing complex calculations or equipment. Furthermore, it minimizes errors associated with contact resistance and lead resistance, making it particularly suitable for low resistance measurements.

Are there any limitations to using a meter bridge for measuring low resistance?

While the meter bridge is highly effective for measuring low resistance, it does have some limitations. It requires careful calibration and precise adjustments to ensure accuracy. The accuracy can also be affected by temperature variations and the uniformity of the wire. Additionally, it may not be suitable for extremely low resistances (in the milliohm range) without additional modifications or more sensitive equipment.

How can one improve the accuracy of low resistance measurements using a meter bridge?

To improve the accuracy of low resistance measurements using a meter bridge, ensure that the wire used is of uniform cross-section and has good conductivity. Calibrate the instrument carefully before use, and make sure the connections are clean and secure to minimize contact resistance. Using a sensitive galvanometer can also help detect smaller imbalances, leading to more precise measurements. Additionally, conducting measurements in a controlled environment to minimize temperature fluctuations can further enhance accuracy.

Back
Top