Mistakes in problem statement (hierarchical modeling)

  • MHB
  • Thread starter kalish1
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Modeling
In summary, the problem statement is asking to find the probability of a random variable $X_i$ being equal to a certain value $k$, given that it follows a Bernoulli distribution with parameters $P_i$ and a beta distribution with parameters $\alpha_i$ and $\beta_i$. The use of $\approx$ is interchangeable with ~ and $(\alpha_i, \beta_i)$ specifies that each $P_i$ has its own set of parameters.
  • #1
kalish1
99
0
I am doing some problems from a practice final and would like to know if the following problem has mistakes in the way it is written. It is throwing me off.

**Problem statement:** Suppose that $(X_1,P_1), \ldots, (X_n,P_n)$ are independent random vectors with $X_i|P_i \approx Bernoulli(P_i), P_i \approx beta(\alpha_i,\beta_i)$, for $i = 1,2,\dots, n$. Find $P(X_i=k)$.

Shouldn't $P(X_i=k)$ be $P(X_i=n)$, and shouldn't $\approx$ be ~, and shouldn't $(\alpha_i, \beta_i)$ be $(\alpha,\beta)$?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
No, the problem statement is correct as written. $P(X_i=k)$ refers to the probability of the random variable $X_i$ being equal to some value $k$. $\approx$ and ~ are used interchangeably and mean "is distributed as". $(\alpha_i, \beta_i)$ refers to the fact that each $P_i$ has its own parameters; it is not necessary for all of them to have the same parameters.
 

FAQ: Mistakes in problem statement (hierarchical modeling)

What are some common mistakes in problem statements for hierarchical modeling?

Some common mistakes in problem statements for hierarchical modeling include not clearly defining the levels and relationships between them, not specifying the variables and parameters to be included in the model, and not considering potential sources of variation and their effect on the model.

How can mistakes in problem statements affect the outcome of hierarchical modeling?

Mistakes in problem statements can lead to biased or inaccurate results in hierarchical modeling. Without a clear and comprehensive problem statement, the model may not accurately reflect the real-world phenomenon being studied, and the resulting conclusions may be flawed or misleading.

What steps can be taken to avoid mistakes in problem statements for hierarchical modeling?

To avoid mistakes in problem statements for hierarchical modeling, it is important to carefully define and identify the levels and relationships between them, clearly specify the variables and parameters to be included in the model, and thoroughly consider potential sources of variation and their impact on the model.

How can hierarchical modeling be used to address mistakes in problem statements?

Hierarchical modeling can help to address mistakes in problem statements by allowing for the incorporation of multiple levels and sources of variation in the model. This can help to account for any oversights or errors in the problem statement and provide a more accurate representation of the phenomenon being studied.

Are there any resources available for identifying and correcting mistakes in problem statements for hierarchical modeling?

Yes, there are several resources available for identifying and correcting mistakes in problem statements for hierarchical modeling. These include textbooks on hierarchical modeling, online tutorials and guides, and consulting with experts in the field. It is also important to carefully review and revise the problem statement during the modeling process to ensure its accuracy and completeness.

Similar threads

Back
Top