Negative Mass: Fact or Fiction?

In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of negative mass and its potential implications in physics. While it may seem counterintuitive, negative mass is not inherently impossible according to the current best theory of gravity, general relativity. Negative mass would behave differently from positive mass, being universally repulsive rather than attractive. The conversation also touches on other examples of seemingly contradictory concepts in physics and the importance of thinking in new ways to understand them.
  • #1
cam875
228
0
someone told me about this and it doesn't make sense to me how it could even be possible. Because if you had something with negative mass it technically wouldn't even be matter now would it? so what i am trying to ask is this just a ridiculous phenomena such as perpetual motion is.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
cam875 said:
someone told me about this and it doesn't make sense to me how it could even be possible. Because if you had something with negative mass it technically wouldn't even be matter now would it?
That's just a question of how you define the word "matter", it doesn't tell you anything about whether stuff with negative mass is possible--most people would probably say photons aren't "matter" either, but they exist. I don't know if there's any evidence for negative mass, though in relativity this should be equivalent to negative energy, and physicists do say the space in between parallel plates in the Casimir effect has negative energy, although without having a quantum theory of gravity I don't think they can be confident that it would actually behave like hypothetical negative mass would be predicted to behave in the context of the current best theory of gravity, general relativity. But I'm pretty sure there's nothing inherently impossible about the theoretical notion of negative mass in general relativity.

If negative mass existed, it wouldn't behave quite like you might expect from science fiction--if you dropped a negative mass object on Earth, it would fall downward just like a positive mass object. But while positive mass would be "universally attractive" in the sense that both positive-mass objects and negative-mass objects would be attracted to a positive-mass planet, negative mass would be "universally repulsive" in the sense that if you could gather a planet-sized collection of negative mass in one place (which would be hard, since the bits would all repel each other), outside positive masses and outside negative masses would both be repelled from the large negative-mass body.
 
  • #3
it doesn't make sense to me how it could even be possible.

A lot of physics doesn't make much sense...until you learn new ways of thinking ...which can involve advanced mathematics...

What is "negative anything" ...for example what is -1? How can you have negative one apple?? Another simple example might be "i" as the sq rt(-1)...does that make "sense"? How can a solution of a "real equation" involved "imagninary" roots? and if it does make sense,and we define x = ict as a "dimension" in time what does that mean?? If you understand how any of these CAN make sense then you are beginning to think in new ways.

To add to Jesse's answer, not disagree with it, negative pressure is theorized to cause the inflationary expansion of the early universe and now powers the cosmological constant expanding the universe. Gravity is not only attractive; Einstein showed negative pressure exerts gravitational repulsion...so there's a lot of "negativity" around that IS difficult to understand.
 

Related to Negative Mass: Fact or Fiction?

What is negative mass?

Negative mass is a hypothetical concept in physics where the mass of an object is less than zero. This means that it would have the opposite properties of regular matter, such as repelling instead of attracting other objects.

Is negative mass real?

At this time, negative mass is still considered a theoretical concept and has not been observed in nature. However, there have been some recent experiments with particles called polaritons that have shown behavior that is similar to what would be expected from negative mass.

Can negative mass be created?

Currently, there is no known way to create negative mass. It would require the manipulation of fundamental particles and their properties, which is beyond our current technological capabilities.

What are the implications of negative mass?

If negative mass were to exist, it would have significant implications for our understanding of physics and the universe. It could potentially explain phenomena such as dark matter and dark energy, and also challenge our current theories of gravity.

Could negative mass be used for space travel?

While negative mass may seem like it would have useful properties for space travel, such as repelling against gravity, it is still a purely theoretical concept and we do not have the technology to create or manipulate it. As such, it is not currently a viable option for space travel.

Similar threads

  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
25
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
12
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Back
Top