Normal Conditional Distribution

[learner928]

Anyone know answer to below.

If two random variables X and Y are both marginally normal, and conditional distribution of Y given any value of X is also normal.

Does this automatically mean the conditional distribution of X given any value of Y also has to be normal? or not necessarily.

 

[chiro]

Hey learner928 and welcome to the forums.

GIven P(Y|X) is Normal, P(X) is Normal, P(Y) is normal so P(X|Y) is proportional to P(Y|X)*P(X) (using a posterior) and if P(Y|X) has normal PDF with P(X) having a normal PDF, then the posterior will also have a normal PDF.

You can prove this by starting off with two PDF expressions P(A) = Normal_PDF_1, P(B) = Normal_PDF_2 and then multiply the two together and show that the product is also a Normal PDF and you're done.

 

[learner928]

Hey learner928 and welcome to the forums.

GIven P(Y|X) is Normal, P(X) is Normal, P(Y) is normal so P(X|Y) is proportional to P(Y|X)*P(X) (using a posterior) and if P(Y|X) has normal PDF with P(X) having a normal PDF, then the posterior will also have a normal PDF.

You can prove this by starting off with two PDF expressions P(A) = Normal_PDF_1, P(B) = Normal_PDF_2 and then multiply the two together and show that the product is also a Normal PDF and you're done.

Thanks Chiro, just to confirm, so your argument still applies even if P(X) and P(Y) are not independent right,

so in conclusion,
Even if P(X) and P(Y) are not independent, if P(X), P(Y) and P(Y|X) are all normal, then P(X|Y) also has to be normal.

 

[chiro]

If they are not independent normal then you will have a covariance matrix with off-diagonal positions, or you will have in general, a relationship where A = f(B) [A and f(A) both normal] so what you should do in this case is use limits that reflect the dependencies (which is what happens in dependent distributions).

You should however be able to prove that the product is normal (even if they are dependent or related) by assuming both have normal PDF and thus the product has a normal PDF.

The big difference will be the region of integration, and how these limits allow you to calculate an actual probability for your final variable.

 

[blue_raver22]

Not necessarily. The conditional distribution of X given any value of Y may or may not be normal. It depends on the relationship between X and Y and their joint distribution. If X and Y are independent, then the conditional distribution of X given any value of Y will also be normal. However, if X and Y are not independent, then the conditional distribution of X given any value of Y may not be normal. It is important to consider the joint distribution of X and Y in order to determine the conditional distribution of X given any value of Y.