- #1
Ackbach
Gold Member
MHB
- 4,155
- 92
The problem with WolframAlpha is several-fold: 1. You can't enter multiple commands. 2. Without paying for WolframAlpha Pro, you can't save generated graphs to your hard drive as files which you can then insert into other documents, such as a $\LaTeX$ document. 3. I've noticed WolframAlpha having trouble interpreting direct Mathematica commands - as if it doesn't know what I'm asking it to do.
Enter Sage Cell Server. You can do things like the following:
The result is a downloadable file that I can insert into a $\LaTeX$ document. You can also save as a pdf if you like, simply by changing the extension in the p.save command there at the end.
If you were looking carefully at my Sage code, you would have noticed a tiny bit of $\LaTeX$ code in there, resulting in the exponent of the m/s$^{2}$ being raised. There is a very tight integration between Sage and $\LaTeX$, which in general raises the bar for CAS packages. Mathematica's integration with $\LaTeX$ is not nearly this good, to my mind.
Downers?
1. You can't save your worksheet. Sage Cell Server mitigates this a bit by providing a "Share" button at the upper-right of any output. According to the Help page for Sage Cell Server, this button provides two links, in addition to a QR code:
Permalink
A URL which contains a compressed version of the code. This is a truly permanent link that does not depend on the server storing the code (since the text is encoded in the URL itself). This URL can be used with a different Sage Cell Server simply by changing the domain name. If the code is too long, the length of the URL may cause problems in some browsers.
Shortened Temporary Link
A shorter URL containing an identifier for the code. The code is stored in a database on the server and retrieved using the ID, so the link will be valid only with a single server, and only as long as the server database retains the input.
However, with all the input being straight ASCII text, you can save the commands to a text file if you like, for later reference.
2. You can't have output automatically $\LaTeX$-ed up, like you can in a regularly installed version of Sage. This is distinct from the occasional $\LaTeX$ stuff like in the plot above. In regular Sage, there's a little checkbox called "Typeset" that turns all of Sage's output into beautiful $\LaTeX$ output via MathJax. This checkbox is not available in the Sage Cell Server. Indeed, the $\LaTeX$ output of Sage (using MathJax, the same as MHB) is one thing prompting me to switch from Mathematica to Sage. I would give Mathematica's input a 9, and its output a 7. For Sage, I would give its input a 7 and its output a 10. However, you can get around this in Sage Cell Server by wrapping the 'view' function around anything you want to typeset in $\LaTeX$. For example:
produces nice enough output.
3. Sage Cell Server doesn't interpret plain English nearly as well as WolframAlpha. That is, Sage Cell Server doesn't interpret plain English at all. So while WA can easily do what you want with "differentiate t^2", Sage Cell Server is going to want
to do the same thing. Not quite so convenient in that case.
However, I think Sage Cell Server is a viable alternative for more complex mathematical calculations, as you can enter multiple commands.
Enter Sage Cell Server. You can do things like the following:
Code:
t,x,v,a=var('t x v a')
x=2*t^3-7*t^2+7*t
v=x.diff(t)
a=v.diff(t)
p1=plot(x,(t,0,2),color="brown")
p2=plot(v,(t,0,2),color="green")
p3=plot(a,(t,0,2),color="blue")
t=text("0",(-0.05,-1),color="black")
p=p1+p2+p3+t
p.axes_labels(['t [sec]','x(brown) [m], v(green) [m/s], a(blue) [m/s$^2$]'])
show(p)
p.save('2-49a.eps')If you were looking carefully at my Sage code, you would have noticed a tiny bit of $\LaTeX$ code in there, resulting in the exponent of the m/s$^{2}$ being raised. There is a very tight integration between Sage and $\LaTeX$, which in general raises the bar for CAS packages. Mathematica's integration with $\LaTeX$ is not nearly this good, to my mind.
Downers?
1. You can't save your worksheet. Sage Cell Server mitigates this a bit by providing a "Share" button at the upper-right of any output. According to the Help page for Sage Cell Server, this button provides two links, in addition to a QR code:
Permalink
A URL which contains a compressed version of the code. This is a truly permanent link that does not depend on the server storing the code (since the text is encoded in the URL itself). This URL can be used with a different Sage Cell Server simply by changing the domain name. If the code is too long, the length of the URL may cause problems in some browsers.
Shortened Temporary Link
A shorter URL containing an identifier for the code. The code is stored in a database on the server and retrieved using the ID, so the link will be valid only with a single server, and only as long as the server database retains the input.
However, with all the input being straight ASCII text, you can save the commands to a text file if you like, for later reference.
2. You can't have output automatically $\LaTeX$-ed up, like you can in a regularly installed version of Sage. This is distinct from the occasional $\LaTeX$ stuff like in the plot above. In regular Sage, there's a little checkbox called "Typeset" that turns all of Sage's output into beautiful $\LaTeX$ output via MathJax. This checkbox is not available in the Sage Cell Server. Indeed, the $\LaTeX$ output of Sage (using MathJax, the same as MHB) is one thing prompting me to switch from Mathematica to Sage. I would give Mathematica's input a 9, and its output a 7. For Sage, I would give its input a 7 and its output a 10. However, you can get around this in Sage Cell Server by wrapping the 'view' function around anything you want to typeset in $\LaTeX$. For example:
Code:
view((x^2+2*x-1)/(2*x+4))3. Sage Cell Server doesn't interpret plain English nearly as well as WolframAlpha. That is, Sage Cell Server doesn't interpret plain English at all. So while WA can easily do what you want with "differentiate t^2", Sage Cell Server is going to want
Code:
x,t=var('x t')
x=t^2
x.diff()However, I think Sage Cell Server is a viable alternative for more complex mathematical calculations, as you can enter multiple commands.