Optimal Packing of Inscribed Circles on a Circle

  • Thread starter fisico
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Circle
In summary, the question asks for the radius r of n circles with total area A when inscribed and non-overlapping on a circle C. The suggested equation of A = n(pi)r^2 may not be correct due to the empty space between the circles. The question is difficult and it is unclear what class it is for. It may not be possible to solve without more information.
  • #1
fisico
28
0
Hi, this is the question:

If the area of a circle C is A and there are n circles of radius r that do not overlap, inscribed on C, what is r?

I was thinking of A = n(pi)r^2, or the area of C equals the sum of the areas of the circles with radius r to get r, but since there is space in between the circles that is not occupied by them, (since the circles do not overlap with each other) then that equation must be wrong.

Help please?

Thank you
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Are you asking what the largest r could be is? Cause clearly if you make r small enough they will fit. If this is the question, it's a really tough one, and I can't think of a way to approach it. Are you sure this is the question, and what kind of class is it for?
 
  • #3
if I say that there are 50 circles, n = 50, inscribed in circle C which has area A, and all adjacent circles are touching each other whithout overlaping, then what is their radius?

That's what the question means. (I think)
 
  • #4
If you're just allowed to put the circles in any pattern you want, ie, you need to find the arrangement with the tightest packing, this is a very difficult problem. So if this is for a class, make sure you've got the problem right, and let us know what kind of class this is. And if it's just a problem you thought of, as far as I can tell, you won't be able to solve it.
 

FAQ: Optimal Packing of Inscribed Circles on a Circle

What is the "Annoying circle question"?

The "Annoying circle question" is a famous mathematical puzzle that involves dividing a circle into smaller equal parts using only a limited number of straight lines.

Who came up with the "Annoying circle question"?

The "Annoying circle question" was originally posed by French mathematician Gabriel Lamé in the 19th century. However, it gained widespread popularity after being shared by Martin Gardner in his "Mathematical Games" column in Scientific American in the 1960s.

How many lines are needed to divide a circle into 4 equal parts?

It is commonly believed that 4 lines are needed to divide a circle into 4 equal parts. However, this is not entirely accurate. While 4 lines can create 4 equal parts, it is also possible to divide a circle into 4 equal parts using only 3 lines in certain cases.

What is the solution to the "Annoying circle question"?

The solution to the "Annoying circle question" varies depending on the specific constraints and rules given. However, in general, the goal is to divide a circle into equal parts using the fewest number of lines possible. There are many different solutions to this puzzle, and finding the most efficient one can be a fun and challenging problem for mathematicians and puzzle enthusiasts alike.

Why is the "Annoying circle question" considered annoying?

The "Annoying circle question" is considered annoying because it can seem deceptively simple at first, but can quickly become complicated and frustrating when trying to find the most efficient solution. It also requires creative thinking and problem-solving skills, making it a challenging puzzle to solve.

Back
Top