PhD Astrophysics, Europe or USA?

[SebastianB]

Hello everyone,

This is my first post! :)

I want to ask you about the pros and cons of doing a PhD in Astrophysics in Europe or USA.

First, I'm going to talk about my current situation. I got my bachelor's degree in physics two months ago, at University of Antioquia, Colombia. I have some experience in researching (presentations, posters, research groups, two ApJ papers, ...), so according to my former Professors it shouldn't be that hard to get admitted in different Universities and I hope it's true!

Some of my former Professors have told me about the pros and cons of each option. According to them, with a PhD in USA I could get a job easily (academic or non-academic job, most of us know about the increasing difficulty to get academic jobs), this is why the USA Universities have better international ranks, more funds, etc. And to be honest, a PhD degree in Harvard, Princeton, Berkeley, bla bla bla, sounds really good :). The main issues with this option are: the PhDs are generally of 5 years!, and the scholarships (really fellowships) are ... scarce, so to speak.

Now, respect to Europe and according to them again, job options are very scarce, inclusively non-academic jobs and probably I must return to Colombia, where a PhD in Astrophysics doesn't help to get non-academic jobs and the academic ones are scarce too. On the other hand, the scholarships use to be much better, and the PhD are generally of 3 years. For example, more specifically, is it a better option doing a PhD in 3 years and after 2 years of pos-doc in USA than a PhD in 5 years (USA)?

So, with all of this in mind and appealing to your experience, what is "the best" option? I know that I must consider things like, what is the more productive University in my research field? Or where are the experts on the field? But I'm really confused and I must decide relatively quickly in order to start to do all the admission procedures. So, please just comment your opinion, I'll really appreciate it!

With my best regards!

Sebastian.

Pd: Sorry for my English.

 

[mfb]

and the PhD are generally of 3 years

That is true, but they usually require a master degree. Add both, and you are at 5 years again.
Europe can be cheaper - the master degree does not cost much (~400-1500 Euro/year in Germany), and PhD positions are paid (enough to live from it). I don't think a PhD in Europe is worse than a PhD in the US.

 

[SebastianB]

Thanks for your answer!

... but they usually require a master degree.

That's true, but here in my local University, undergraduate physics takes 5 year unfortunately, so we must take courses relatively advanced (and sometimes useless), because of that some graduates students have achieved to get admitted in PhD programs in Europe directly.

I don't think a PhD in Europe is worse than a PhD in the US.

I don't think that either, inclusively in Europe are the most prominent experts in my research field! My only consideration about US is due to job opportunities, otherwise, I'd choose Europe without giving it a second thought.

Regards.

 

[mfb]

Well, you can get a job in the US with a PhD from Europe, too (and vice versa).

 

[Matrix0]

Hello Sebastian,

First of all, congratulations on completing your bachelor's degree in physics and having a strong background in research! It sounds like you have a lot of potential and options for your PhD in astrophysics.

I cannot give you a definitive answer on whether Europe or the USA is the best option for your PhD. Both have their own advantages and disadvantages, and it ultimately depends on your personal goals and priorities.

In terms of job opportunities, it is true that the USA has a larger and more diverse job market, especially in the field of academia. However, this does not mean that Europe does not have any job opportunities for astrophysicists. In fact, many European universities and research institutions have strong astrophysics programs and offer opportunities for both academic and non-academic careers. It may require more effort and networking to find job opportunities in Europe, but they do exist.

In terms of funding, it is true that scholarships and fellowships in Europe tend to be more generous compared to those in the USA. However, this does not necessarily mean that you will have a better financial situation in Europe. The cost of living and taxes may also play a role in your overall financial situation. It is important to consider these factors as well when making your decision.

In terms of the duration of the PhD program, it is true that PhD programs in the USA are generally longer compared to those in Europe. However, this does not necessarily mean that a longer program is better. What is important is the quality and productivity of your research during your PhD, regardless of the duration. Additionally, the length of the program may also depend on your own progress and efficiency in completing your research.

Ultimately, the "best" option for you will depend on your personal goals and priorities. Consider factors such as the research opportunities and strengths of the universities in both Europe and the USA, as well as your own personal preferences for location, funding, and career goals. It may also be helpful to reach out to current PhD students or researchers in both regions to gain more insight and advice.

I wish you the best of luck in making your decision and in your future studies in astrophysics!

Best regards,