- #36
f95toli
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 3,509
- 1,071
Alastair McD said:The TED talk does not say "Photon is a particle and a wave structure phenomenon at the same time". It says that light sometimes behaves like a particle and sometimes like a wave. It can't do both at the same time! I am saying that it behave like a particle when the wave function has collapsed, and it behaves like a probability wave of direction until it collapses, by being detected, or hitting an object. You don't know its exact path until it is detected.
That is not quite correct either. First of all. there is no wavefunction for the photon, at least not in the usual sense (you can define quantities that are a bit similar to a wavefunction). Secondly, it is possible to create states of light where it behaves very much like a particle (so-called Fock states), but these are unusual and not created by any conventional source of light (including lasers); most of the time classical (wave) EM works fine.
However, in general all we can say is that light behaves as if it sometimes has particle-like or/or wave-like properties; but this does not means that it "is" (whatever that means) either a wave or a particle (or even a mixture of the two). Note also that the "nature" of light is very well defined in the (complete) theory of light (quantum electrodynamics) so there is no unsolved mystery here. The issue in this context is that you need to know a fair bit of math to understand QED: there is no easy way to explain it and you can certainly not use classical concepts to do so if you want to be accurate.
The best popular description of what light really "is" I've come across is Feynman's book on QED.