Problem with Improper Integration - Is Zero the Correct Answer?

  • Thread starter killerfish
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Integrate
In summary, the conversation is about a problem with improper integration. The homework statement involves finding the value of an integral, and the person asking for help got a zero for the answer. They are wondering if this is correct and ask for clarification on how to solve it. The person helping them suggests that they should integrate \int_{-T/2}^{T/2} dt and substitute in the boundary values. The actual function, g(t), is given as g(t) = cos(2\pif0t) - jsin(2\pif0t).
  • #1
killerfish
16
0
Hi again,

I have a problem regarding improper integration.

Homework Statement

feafea.JPG


Refer to the image. I tried to solve and got zero for the answer. Is that correct? I refer to my actual problem it seem like it don't won't this way...

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
suppose that g(t)=1, what is the value of the integral?
 
  • #3
benorin said:
suppose that g(t)=1, what is the value of the integral?

If 1 is integrated, we get t and then sub in the boundary value the answer still 0?

here the actual g(t) suppose to be g(t) = cos(2[tex]\pi[/tex]f0t) - jsin(2[tex]\pi[/tex]f0t).
 
Last edited:
  • #4
killerfish said:
If 1 is integrated, we get t and then sub in the boundary value the answer still 0?
Are you saying that you are not capable of integrating
[tex]\int_{-T/2}^{T/2} dt[/tex]
or you just haven't bothered to?

here the actual g(t) suppose to be g(t) = cos(2[tex]\pi[/tex]f0t) - jsin(2[tex]\pi[/tex]f0t).
 

FAQ: Problem with Improper Integration - Is Zero the Correct Answer?

What is the problem with improper integration?

The problem with improper integration is that it can lead to incorrect solutions for a given integral. Improper integration occurs when the limits of integration are infinite or when the integrand is undefined at certain points. This can result in a solution of zero, which may not be the correct answer.

Why might zero be the incorrect answer for an improper integral?

Zero can be the incorrect answer for an improper integral because it does not take into account the behavior of the integrand at the boundaries of integration. For example, if the integrand approaches infinity at one of the boundaries, the integral should also approach infinity, not zero.

How can we determine if zero is the correct answer for an improper integral?

To determine if zero is the correct answer for an improper integral, we must evaluate the integral using proper integration techniques. This may involve redefining the limits of integration or breaking the integral into smaller, solvable parts. It is important to consider the behavior of the integrand at the boundaries and whether or not it approaches a finite value.

What are some common mistakes when dealing with improper integrals?

One common mistake when dealing with improper integrals is assuming that the integral will always converge to a finite value. Improper integrals can also have multiple solutions or no solution at all. Another mistake is not taking into account the behavior of the integrand at the boundaries of integration.

How can we avoid getting the incorrect answer for an improper integral?

To avoid getting the incorrect answer for an improper integral, it is important to carefully consider the behavior of the integrand at the boundaries of integration and use proper integration techniques. It may also be helpful to graph the integrand to visually understand its behavior. If in doubt, it is best to break the integral into smaller, solvable parts or consult with a mathematician or other expert.

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Back
Top