Prove Constant Function Cannot Satisfy Condition for r>1

In summary: It doesn't say that IF f is a constant THEN the condition holds. So you can't just give a counterexample and say that therefore it's false, because it doesn't even say that it's true. It says that IF the condition holds, THEN f is a constant. So you can only conclude that if f is NOT a constant function, then the condition must fail. That's all it says.In summary, the conditions given do not necessarily prove that f is a constant function. The inequality may fail for certain choices of r and f. It is possible that there is a typo and it should say |f(x) - f(y)| <= |x - y|^r instead.
  • #1
Treadstone 71
275
0
"Let r be a rational number greater than 1. Let f:R->R be a function that satisfies the condition that for all real numbers x and y,

[tex]|f(x)-f(y)|\leq (x-y)^r[/tex]

Prove that f is a constant."

Perhaps there's some subtlety which I misunderstood, but even a constant function fails to satisfy the conditions for some choice of r. For instance, let r=3 and f be a constant. Let x<y, and the inequality fails, i.e.,

[tex]|f(x)-f(y)|=0\leq (x-y)^3 <0[/tex]
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The question says that IF f satisfies this condition THEN it is a constant, not IF f is a constant THEN it satisfies the condition. If the thing you're asked to prove is true, then given what you just showed when r = 3, you can only conclude that NO function f (constant or otherwise) satisfies the condition.
 
  • #3
But since x and y are arbitrary, x-y could be negative. In that case, if r is some rational number with an odd numerator and an even denominator, this whole thing fails, regardless of what kind of function it is.
 
  • #4
Probably just a typo, it should probably say

|f(x) - f(y)| <= |x - y|^r.
 
  • #5
If r is the type you suggested, then since x-y could be negative, the condition wouldn't hold, as you point out. Again, I repeat, it says IF the condition holds THEN f is a constant.
 

FAQ: Prove Constant Function Cannot Satisfy Condition for r>1

What does it mean for a constant function to satisfy a condition for r>1?

A constant function is a mathematical function where the output value is always the same, regardless of the input value. In order for a constant function to satisfy a condition for r>1, the output value must remain constant when multiplied by a value greater than 1.

Why is it important to prove that a constant function cannot satisfy a condition for r>1?

Proving that a constant function cannot satisfy a condition for r>1 is important in order to understand the limitations of a constant function and its applicability in certain mathematical situations. It also helps to identify the range of values for which a constant function is valid.

How can a constant function be represented mathematically?

A constant function can be represented as f(x) = c, where c is a constant value and x is the input variable. This means that no matter what value x takes on, the output value will always be c.

What are the conditions for r>1?

The condition for r>1 means that the value of r, which represents a scaling factor, must be greater than 1. This condition is often used in mathematical equations involving growth or decay.

What is an example of a condition for r>1 that a constant function cannot satisfy?

An example of a condition for r>1 that a constant function cannot satisfy is the equation f(x) = cx, where c is a constant value. This condition requires the output value to increase as the input value increases, which is not possible with a constant function.

Back
Top