- #1
danago
Gold Member
- 1,123
- 4
Let [tex]\vec{a} \ne 0[/tex] be a fixed vector in R3.
(a) Prove that the set of all vectors [tex]\vec{x} \in R^3[/tex] satisfying [tex]\vec{a}.\vec{x}=0[/tex] is a subspace of R^3. Describe this set geometrically.
(b) Is the set of all vectors [tex]\vec{x} \in R^3[/tex] satisfying [tex]\vec{a} \times \vec{x}=0[/tex] a subspace of R3?For part (a), i thought about the problem geometrically and id be inclined to say that it is a subspace. The zero dot product implies that a and x are orthogonal, and so the set of all x will be a plane through the origin (since <0,0>.a=0 for any a) which is perpendicular to a.
Analytically, i proved it by letting p and q be vectors such that p.a=q.a=0. I then showed that any linear combination of these two vectors is also perpendicular to a.
(kp+lq).a=k(p.a)+l(q.a)=0
Is that correct?
Its part (b) where I am a bit stuck. If the cross product of two vectors is the zero vector, this implies that they are parallel, yea? So x is some element of the set of all vectors which are parallel to a? Since the linear combination of any two vectors parallel to a will also be parallel to a, can we conclude that the set of all x is a subspace of R3?
Now, if my reasoning is correct, how could i go about showing this analytically? I guess it comes down to showing that the cross product being zero implies that the vectors are parallel; once i can show this i can do the rest myself.
Thanks in advance,
Dan.
(a) Prove that the set of all vectors [tex]\vec{x} \in R^3[/tex] satisfying [tex]\vec{a}.\vec{x}=0[/tex] is a subspace of R^3. Describe this set geometrically.
(b) Is the set of all vectors [tex]\vec{x} \in R^3[/tex] satisfying [tex]\vec{a} \times \vec{x}=0[/tex] a subspace of R3?For part (a), i thought about the problem geometrically and id be inclined to say that it is a subspace. The zero dot product implies that a and x are orthogonal, and so the set of all x will be a plane through the origin (since <0,0>.a=0 for any a) which is perpendicular to a.
Analytically, i proved it by letting p and q be vectors such that p.a=q.a=0. I then showed that any linear combination of these two vectors is also perpendicular to a.
(kp+lq).a=k(p.a)+l(q.a)=0
Is that correct?
Its part (b) where I am a bit stuck. If the cross product of two vectors is the zero vector, this implies that they are parallel, yea? So x is some element of the set of all vectors which are parallel to a? Since the linear combination of any two vectors parallel to a will also be parallel to a, can we conclude that the set of all x is a subspace of R3?
Now, if my reasoning is correct, how could i go about showing this analytically? I guess it comes down to showing that the cross product being zero implies that the vectors are parallel; once i can show this i can do the rest myself.
Thanks in advance,
Dan.