Proving Equality of Rational Functions with Two Polynomials

In summary, the two rational functions b(x)/f(x) and c(x)/g(x) can only be true when b(x) = c(x) = 0.
  • #1
silvermane
Gold Member
117
0

Homework Statement


We have two polynomials F(x) and g(x) over a field, and suppose that we know gcd(f,g)=1.
Consider two rational functions b(x)/f(x) and c(x)/g(x) in which we have deg(b)<deg(f) and deg(c)<deg(g). Prove that b(x)/f(x) = c(x)/g(x) can only be true when b(x) = c(x) = 0


The Attempt at a Solution


I really need help starting this proof.
So far, I have that f(x) won't divide b(x) since deg(b)<deg(f), and g(x) won't divide c(x) since deg(c)<deg(g). Because of this, we cross multiply to obtain:

b(x)*g(x) = c(x)*f(x)

But then it gets hazy here.
I know that f(x) and g(x) won't cancel out since their gcd=1, and b(x) must equal c(x) for them to cancel out. But then we'll be left with g(x) = f(x), so b(x) must equal c(x) and both terms must be equal to 0.

Is that all I have to do/say? It seems too simple.
Thanks for your help in advance! It means a lot! :blushing:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
silvermane said:

b(x)*g(x) = c(x)*f(x)

g(x) divides the LHS so it must divide the RHS. Since gcd(g,f) = 1, this means g(x) must divide c(x). By the same reasoning, f(x) must divide b(x). But you have some constraints on the degrees of these polynomials. What do the constraints imply?
 
  • #3
By the way, the question may not make any sense as worded. If b(x) is the zero polynomial, what is deg(b)? Some people would say deg(b) is undefined in that case, others would set it to [itex]-\infty[/itex]. What is the definition in this context?
 
  • #4
jbunniii said:
g(x) divides the LHS so it must divide the RHS. Since gcd(g,f) = 1, this means g(x) must divide c(x). By the same reasoning, f(x) must divide b(x). But you have some constraints on the degrees of these polynomials. What do the constraints imply?

The constraints imply that f(x) can't divide b(x) and g(x) can't divide c(x). So then we would have that they must be 0 for the two sides to be equal?
 
  • #5
silvermane said:
The constraints imply that f(x) can't divide b(x) and g(x) can't divide c(x). So then we would have that they must be 0 for the two sides to be equal?

Or, putting it more pedantically, f(x) cannot divide a polynomial of lower degree unless that polynomial is zero. [This assumes "degree" is defined for the zero polynomial.] Therefore b(x) must be the zero polynomial, and similarly for c(x).
 
  • #6
jbunniii said:
Or, putting it more pedantically, f(x) cannot divide a polynomial of lower degree unless that polynomial is zero. [This assumes "degree" is defined for the zero polynomial.] Therefore b(x) must be the zero polynomial, and similarly for c(x).

Ah, that makes sense. Thanks so much for your help :smile:
 

FAQ: Proving Equality of Rational Functions with Two Polynomials

1. What is the definition of a proof involving two functions?

A proof involving two functions is a mathematical argument that demonstrates the relationship between two functions, typically by showing that one function is equal to the other or that they have the same properties.

2. How do you prove that two functions are equal?

To prove that two functions are equal, you must show that they have the same output for every input. This can be done by either using algebraic manipulation or by using mathematical properties and theorems.

3. Can you use proofs involving two functions in any branch of mathematics?

Yes, proofs involving two functions can be used in various branches of mathematics, including calculus, algebra, and number theory.

4. Are there any common techniques or strategies for proving the equality of two functions?

Yes, some common techniques for proving the equality of two functions include using direct substitution, using the definition of a function, and using algebraic manipulation.

5. Are there any particular properties or characteristics of functions that make proving their equality easier?

Yes, certain properties of functions, such as being one-to-one or onto, can make proving their equality easier. Additionally, if the functions are continuous or differentiable, this can also simplify the proof process.

Similar threads

Replies
14
Views
835
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
2K
Back
Top