Proving R is Not a Domain: A Counterexample Approach

  • Thread starter playa007
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Domain
In summary, R = {0.5(a+b(root2)) : a,b are integers} is not a domain because it is not closed under multiplication, and therefore cannot be a commutative ring.
  • #1
playa007
29
0

Homework Statement


Show that R = {0.5(a+b(root2)) : a,b are integers} is not a domain


2. Homework Equations
A commutative ring (non trivial) is a domain iff (ab=0 => a=0 or b=0)

The Attempt at a Solution


I've try to construct a counterexample where x, y in R and xy=0 but x,y=/=0 but this has been hard to do since i realize that x and y mostly like have to be "conjugates of each other" and xy is of some form 0.25(a^2 - 2b^2) and (a^2 - 2b^2) = 0 and its impossible to do this just by using integers for a and b.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
If x= 0.5(a+ bsqrt(2)) and y= 0.5(c+ dsqrt(2)) then xy= 0.25(ac+ (ad+bc)sqrt(2)+ 2cd)

Obviously you can ignore the "0.5". You need to find a, b, c, and d, non-zero, so that ad+ bc= 0 and ac+ 2cd= 0.

In your equations, you seem to be assuming x=y.
 
  • #3
doesn't xy=0.25(ac+2bd+(ad+bc)sqrt(2))=0.5 ( (ac+2bd)/2 + sqrt(2) (ad+bc)/2) imply that R is not closed under multiplication? since (ac+2bd)/2 and (ad+bc)/2 are not necessarily integers. R is therefore not even a ring.
 

FAQ: Proving R is Not a Domain: A Counterexample Approach

What does it mean when a show is not a domain?

When a show is not a domain, it means that the show does not have a well-defined set of inputs and outputs. This could be due to a variety of factors such as the show being improvised or relying heavily on audience participation.

How can you tell if a show is not a domain?

You can tell if a show is not a domain by looking at the structure and format of the show. If the show is highly structured with a predetermined plot and dialogue, it is likely a domain. However, if the show is more fluid and relies on spontaneous interactions and reactions, it is likely not a domain.

Why is it important to know if a show is not a domain?

Knowing if a show is not a domain is important for understanding how the show is created and performed. It can also help audiences manage their expectations and better appreciate the unique aspects of the show.

Can a show be both a domain and not a domain?

Yes, a show can have elements of a domain and also not be a domain. For example, a scripted play may have moments of improvisation or audience interaction, making it a combination of both a domain and not a domain.

Are there any benefits to a show not being a domain?

Yes, there are benefits to a show not being a domain. It allows for more creativity and spontaneity in the performance, making each show unique and unpredictable. It also creates a more interactive and immersive experience for the audience.

Back
Top