Proving Subgroup Equality in Group Theory

  • Thread starter ranoo
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses proving two statements regarding a subgroup H of a group G. The first statement states that Ha is equal to H if and only if a belongs to H. The second statement states that H^2 is equal to H. The conversation also clarifies the meaning of Ha and the definition of a subgroup. It also provides hints for proving the statements.
  • #1
ranoo
9
0

Homework Statement



let H a subgroup of G. Prove that:
1) Ha=H iff a belong to H
2) H2=H

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution

 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
ranoo said:

Homework Statement



let H a subgroup of G. Prove that:
1) Ha=H iff a belong to H
2) H2=H
What does Ha mean? What does it mean to multiply a subgroup by itself?
 
  • #3
I don't know, like this we took in the homework.
 
  • #4
Ha is the set containing all elements of the form h*a, where h is in H.

What is the definition of a subgroup? It must non-empty, closed under multiplication and closed under inversion. So if Ha = H, then [tex] h_{1}a = h_{2}[/tex]. What does this say about a?

If a is in H on the other hand, and H is closed under multiplication, what does this say about Ha?

Finally, to prove that H^2=H, we need to show that [tex] H^{2} \subseteq H [/tex] and [tex] H \subseteq H^{2} [/tex]. First, naively, which one is definitely contained in which? Next, if H is closed under multiplication, what does this say about the relation between H and H^2?

Good luck!
 
  • #5
thank you very much
 

FAQ: Proving Subgroup Equality in Group Theory

How do I know if I have proven a problem?

The best way to know if you have successfully proven a problem is to follow the scientific method. This includes formulating a hypothesis, designing a controlled experiment, collecting and analyzing data, and drawing a conclusion based on the evidence. If your conclusion aligns with your initial hypothesis and is supported by your data, then you have successfully proven your problem.

What are some common mistakes to avoid when trying to prove a problem?

Some common mistakes to avoid when trying to prove a problem include not having a clear hypothesis, using biased or insufficient data, and failing to control for variables in the experiment. It is important to carefully plan and execute your experiment to minimize these potential errors.

Can a problem ever be definitively proven?

In science, it is rare for a problem to be definitively proven. This is because new evidence or information can always arise that may challenge or alter our understanding of a problem. However, through rigorous experimentation and data analysis, we can come to strong conclusions that are supported by the evidence we have at the time.

How can I make my proof more convincing?

To make your proof more convincing, it is important to use multiple lines of evidence and to replicate your results. This means conducting the same experiment multiple times and obtaining similar results each time. Additionally, you can try to address any potential counterarguments or alternative explanations for your findings in your conclusion.

What should I do if my proof does not support my hypothesis?

If your proof does not support your hypothesis, it is important to carefully examine your data and experiment to identify any potential weaknesses or flaws. Consider revisiting your hypothesis or adjusting your experimental design to address these issues. It is also important to acknowledge and discuss unexpected results in your conclusion.

Back
Top