Proving the Closedness of the Boundary of a Subset in Rn

  • Thread starter ayas
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Analysis
In summary: So eventually, every neighborhood of x must contain a member of S, contradicting that bd(S) is not closed. In summary, ayas suggests that the boundary of a subset is closed if and only if the subset contains all of its boundary points.
  • #1
ayas
4
0
Hello,
I know how to start but I don't know how to end that proof. It's supposed to be easy:
Let S a subset of Rn.
PROVE THAT the boundary of S is a closed set.
(I'll use d for delta, so dS is my convention for "the boundary of S").

So here I go:
dS is closed iff it contains all of its boundary points,
so dS is closed iff d(dS) is included in dS.
Let x be any point such that x belongs to d(dS).
So for any Ball B(r, x), r>0, (ie centered at x),
| B intersection dS is not empty
| and B interesection (dS)complement is not empty.
(the second line is equivalent to) B interesection (interiorOfS union exteriorOfS) is not empty

Now what's next??
Thanks for your suggestions. If you do have a suggestion, please don't skip a step or don't bypass a detail because it seems obvious (trust me, nothing is obvious to the one who doesn't know yet!)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Have you tried showing that the complement of dS is open?
 
  • #3
the boundary is the complement of the interior which is easily shown to be open. qed. oops. my bad. that was just said.
 
  • #4
There are several different ways of characterizing closed sets. One is "complement of an open set"- that's the one morphism and mathwonk are suggesting. Another is "a set that contains all its boundary points"- that's the one ayas is using.

ayas, have you considered an indirect proof? If bd(S) is not closed then there must be some member, x, of bd(bd(S)) that is NOT in bd(S). Since x is in bd(bd(S)) every neighborhood of x contains some member, y, of bd(S). Now there is a neighborhood of y that is a subset of the original neighborhood . . .
 

FAQ: Proving the Closedness of the Boundary of a Subset in Rn

What is simple analysis?

Simple analysis is a method used by scientists to break down complex problems or data into smaller, more manageable parts. It involves identifying patterns, relationships, and trends within the data to gain a deeper understanding of the subject being studied.

Why is simple analysis important?

Simple analysis allows scientists to make sense of large amounts of data and draw meaningful conclusions. It also helps identify any errors or inconsistencies in the data, leading to more accurate results and conclusions.

What are some common techniques used in simple analysis?

Some common techniques used in simple analysis include data visualization, statistical analysis, and data mining. These techniques help to organize, summarize, and interpret the data in a more meaningful way.

Can simple analysis be used in any field of science?

Yes, simple analysis can be used in any field of science that deals with data and information. It is a fundamental tool for researchers in fields such as biology, chemistry, physics, and social sciences.

How does simple analysis differ from complex analysis?

Simple analysis focuses on breaking down complex problems into smaller parts and finding patterns and relationships within the data. On the other hand, complex analysis involves using advanced mathematical and statistical techniques to study complex systems and phenomena.

Similar threads

Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Back
Top