Quantum & Classical Potential?

In summary: potential is often used as a descriptor to describe the ability of an object or situation to produce a wide variety of results or outcomes.
  • #1
quantumcarl
770
0
Here is part of an article that discusses what Bohm called "Quantum Potential"

Essentially, Bohm and his school re-interpreted the mathematics of Quantum Mechanics and extracted a part of the equation which they called the quantum potential. The quantum potential is non-local, and is responsible for all the non-local effects predicted by the theory.

The quantum potential guides, say, the path of an electron in a way similar to the way a radio beacon can guide an airplane coming in for a landing at the airport. It is the jets, ailerons, rudder, etc. on the plane that mechanically determines where the plane is going, but the beacon guides the way.

In Bohm's ontology electrons really are particles. For the case of, for example, the double slit experiment for electrons, each electron goes through either the upper slit or the lower slit; it has a definite path independent of its observation. However, the quantum potential is different depending on whether the other slit is open or closed; since this potential is non-local it can instantaneously change if the other slit is opened or closed. Thus the electron paths are different depending on whether or not the other slit is open.

From:http://www.upscale.utoronto.ca/GeneralInterest/Harrison/BellsTheorem/BellsTheorem.html

Here is a summary of Issac Newton's definition of "Potential Energy" which I suppose can be classified as Classical Potential... although there are a billion physicists writing papers about "classical potential" that have nothing to do with Issac's definition of potential.

Potential Energy:

Potential energy exists whenever an object which has mass has a position within a force field. The most everyday example of this is the position of objects in the Earth's gravitational field.
The potential energy of an object in this case is given by the relation:

PE = mgh

where

PE = Energy (in Joules)
m = mass (in kilograms)
g = gravitational acceleration of the Earth (9.8 m/sec2)
h = height above Earth's surface (in meters)

From: http://jersey.uoregon.edu/vlab/PotentialEnergy/

Does the word "potential" describe the same condition regardless of it being used in a Quantum context or a Classical context?

Thank you for considering my question here.:smile:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I wouldn't depend on Newton's definitions for my understanding of concepts like potential. These ideas remained at a pretty primitive level until the nineteenth century, when people like Poussin, Green, Jacobi, and Dirichlet made a major improvement in understandiing.

The traditional way to acieve a quantum theory is to quantize a classical theory. In that process the variables in the classical theory become operators in the quantum theory. Energy becomes a Hamiltonian operator.
 
  • #3
selfAdjoint said:
I wouldn't depend on Newton's definitions for my understanding of concepts like potential. These ideas remained at a pretty primitive level until the nineteenth century, when people like Poussin, Green, Jacobi, and Dirichlet made a major improvement in understandiing.

The traditional way to acieve a quantum theory is to quantize a classical theory. In that process the variables in the classical theory become operators in the quantum theory. Energy becomes a Hamiltonian operator.

Can potential can be quantizised by assigning a value to a constant unit of potential? I'm not sure what a constant unit of potential could be... perhaps a calorie or Joule of energy,say?!

Potential is defined in layman's terms as the ability and flexibility for an entity to produce a wide variety of results or outcomes.
ie: The potential of fire can be any number of things ranging from the complete destruction of an object to the creation of fine ceramics.
Does this definition change when applied to quantum physics?

It wouldn't surprise me to see the definition of one word change from application to application.
ie:, the term "slip" describes an action often associated with a bannana peel and a pedestrian.

However, in ceramics, "slip" describes clay with a lot of water in it and is often used as a glaze but also lubricates the "throwing" of a cylindrical ceramic object. Langauge is so fickle:rolleyes:

Thank you for you input!
 
Last edited:
  • #4
I suppose as primitive as Newton's attempt was at quantizising potential it was in the spirit of quantizisation and an attempt to objectify the idea of potential.

After considering the pedestrian and the scientific uses of the word, potential, I concluded, (with some help from Zapper z's comments in the thread "Yet Another Cat Question"/Quantum Physics section) that the word Potential is a descriptor or adjective that is applied to an object or situation.

The pedestrian (after Zz) use of the word potential describes the statistical probablilities that are available in any given situation or object. The probablities inherent in a situation or object are arrived at by making note of the elements that compose one or the other. These elements and combinations of elements can then be used to calculate various results/outcomes that are dependent upon various but specific combinations of the elements. This determines the potential(s) that exist in any given set of events.

In physics, as Zz pointed out, potential is measured such as in what he used as an example, electrostatic potential. Here, the number of probabilities are constant and the elements of the situation or object (electrostatic charge) are minimal in number. The potential charge of an electrostatic event is predicted by using a tried and true formula. And I suppose one can apply similar formuli to various other simplistic events like electrostatic charge.
 

FAQ: Quantum & Classical Potential?

What is the difference between quantum and classical potential?

The main difference between quantum and classical potential lies in their underlying principles. Classical potential refers to the potential energy associated with the position of an object in a classical system, whereas quantum potential is the potential energy associated with the position of a particle in a quantum system. Additionally, classical potential is continuous and deterministic, while quantum potential is discrete and probabilistic.

How is quantum potential related to the uncertainty principle?

The uncertainty principle, a fundamental principle of quantum mechanics, states that it is impossible to know both the position and momentum of a particle with absolute precision. This is because the act of measuring one property affects the other. In the context of quantum potential, the uncertainty principle implies that the potential energy of a particle cannot be known with certainty, and can only be described probabilistically.

How does quantum potential affect the behavior of particles?

Quantum potential has a significant impact on the behavior of particles in the microscopic world. It introduces the concept of wave-particle duality, where particles can behave as both particles and waves. This is because the potential energy of a particle is described by a wave function, which gives the probability of finding the particle at a particular location.

Can quantum potential be observed in experiments?

Quantum potential itself cannot be directly observed in experiments. However, its effects can be observed through various phenomena, such as the double-slit experiment, where particles exhibit wave-like behavior due to their potential energy being described by a wave function. Additionally, the principles of quantum potential are essential for understanding and developing technologies such as transistors, lasers, and MRI machines.

What are the practical applications of quantum potential?

Quantum potential has numerous practical applications in fields such as quantum computing, cryptography, and medical imaging. It also plays a crucial role in understanding the behavior of matter at the subatomic level and in developing new materials and technologies. Additionally, the principles of quantum potential have led to significant advancements in fundamental physics, such as the development of the standard model of particle physics.

Similar threads

Replies
36
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
995
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
23
Views
4K
Replies
22
Views
2K
Back
Top