Real Line Intervals as Closed, Bounded Non-Compact Spaces

  • Thread starter symbol0
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of a closed and bounded non-compact topological space, specifically in the context of an interval (a,b) in the real line. The concept is confirmed to be correct, but there is some discussion on the meaning of boundedness in a topological space and how it relates to metrics. Ultimately, it is concluded that boundedness is not a topological property and the example of (a,b) being homeomorphic to the unbounded real line is given as evidence.
  • #1
symbol0
77
0
I had this thought:
Every interval (a,b) of the real line is a closed and bounded non-compact topological space.

Is this correct?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Interval (a,b) is not closed.
 
  • #3
symbol0 said:
I had this thought:
Every interval (a,b) of the real line is a closed and bounded non-compact topological space.

Is this correct?
Closed and non-compact in what space? Trivially, any topological space is closed in itself (which is why we don't really say that something is a "closed topological space"), is this what you mean?

I don't know what a bounded topological space is, but it is bounded as a metric space with the usual metric.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
Yes, that's what I meant: a closed bounded metric space (closed in itself).
Thanks for clarifying this for me.
 
  • #5
boundedness isn't really a topological property, for any metrizable space, one can introduce a new metric:

d' = min{d, 1}

and the resulting topology will be the same and the metric will be bounded. More obviously and specifically to your example, (a,b) is homeomorphic to the real line, which isn't bounded. (hence, boundedness isn't really a topological property).
 
  • #6
Thanks tim_lou
 

FAQ: Real Line Intervals as Closed, Bounded Non-Compact Spaces

What does "Am I right?" mean?

"Am I right?" is a common phrase used to confirm whether one's opinion or statement is correct. It is often used to seek validation or agreement from others.

Why do people ask "Am I right?"

People may ask "Am I right?" to confirm their own thoughts or beliefs, to gauge the opinions of others, or to seek reassurance or validation.

Is "Am I right?" a rhetorical question?

It can be considered a rhetorical question, as the person asking it may already believe they are right and are using the question to emphasize their point.

Can "Am I right?" be considered a form of self-doubt?

In some cases, yes. Asking "Am I right?" may indicate that the person is unsure of their thoughts or opinions and is seeking confirmation from others.

How is "Am I right?" different from "Am I wrong?"

While both phrases seek validation, "Am I right?" is often used to confirm one's own thoughts or beliefs, while "Am I wrong?" is typically used to ask for correction or clarification.

Similar threads

Back
Top