- #1
Ezio3.1415
- 159
- 1
What is the difference between real photons and virtual photons?
Real vs. Virtual Photons: A Comparison
- Thread starter Ezio3.1415
- Start date
-
- Tags
- Comparison Photons Virtual
In summary: However, in order to calculate the virtual fields, we use the mathematical approach first developed by Feynman. You won't see one, but they play an important role in the calculations.
- #2
haushofer
Science Advisor
- 3,027
- 1,557
Real photons satisfy Einstein's energy relation (or: they are on-shell). Virtual photons don't. As a consequence, the first can be directly measured, the second cannot.
- #3
Ezio3.1415
- 159
- 1
Virtual photons are the force carriers of e.m. While real photons are little packets of energy... When two electrons repulse each other they do it because of the interaction of virtual photons... If they exchaned energy real photon would be emitted and absorbed... And in case of virtual photons no energy is exchanged... Did I get it?
- #4
dipstik
- 127
- 4
you have to be careful about the two repelling each other argument...
how would a proton and electron attract each other with that logic?
how would a proton and electron attract each other with that logic?
- #5
tiny-tim
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
- 25,839
- 258
Welcome to PF!
Hi Ezio3.1415! Welcome to PF!
real photons are physics (they exist)
virtual photons are just maths (they don't)
no, they do so because of the fields
the virtual photons in the maths help us to calculate the fields
Hi Ezio3.1415! Welcome to PF!
Ezio3.1415 said:
real photons are physics (they exist)
virtual photons are just maths (they don't)
Ezio3.1415 said:
no, they do so because of the fields
the virtual photons in the maths help us to calculate the fields
- #6
Mark M
- 527
- 1
As tiny-tim explains, virtual photons appear in between the actual interactions, for the mathematical approach to QFT first used by Feynman. Normal photons enter into interactions (vertices of Feynman diagrams), and they can also emerge. As indicated by the name, you won't see one.
- #7
Ezio3.1415
- 159
- 1
Dipstick: I would say the same thing I guess... Interaction!
Tim: Thank you... Hope to get a lot of help here... The forum's so active... :)
But I thought standard model visualizes the field with the help of field particles,doesn't it? Or is it just the maths? But it makes total sense... It explains why the range of forces with virtual particles(the force carriers) so well...
Mark:
Tim: Thank you... Hope to get a lot of help here... The forum's so active... :)
But I thought standard model visualizes the field with the help of field particles,doesn't it? Or is it just the maths? But it makes total sense... It explains why the range of forces with virtual particles(the force carriers) so well...
Mark:
Can u explain that without Feynman diagram?
FAQ: Real vs. Virtual Photons: A Comparison
What is the difference between real and virtual photons?
Real photons are particles of light that can be observed and measured, whereas virtual photons are theoretical particles that are used to explain interactions between charged particles.
How do real and virtual photons behave differently?
Real photons travel at the speed of light and can be absorbed or emitted by particles, while virtual photons do not have a measurable speed and are only exchanged between particles during interactions.
Can real and virtual photons be distinguished in experiments?
No, real and virtual photons cannot be distinguished in experiments. Both types of photons have the same energy and properties, and their effects are indistinguishable.
How are real and virtual photons related to quantum electrodynamics?
Real and virtual photons are fundamental to the theory of quantum electrodynamics, which describes the interactions between charged particles and electromagnetic forces. Virtual photons are used to explain the exchange of energy and momentum between particles.
Are virtual photons just a theoretical concept or do they have real-world applications?
Virtual photons are primarily a theoretical concept used in quantum mechanics, but they have real-world applications in fields such as particle physics and quantum computing. Virtual photons play a crucial role in understanding the behavior of particles at the subatomic level.