Requesting constructive criticism for my paper

In summary, the author is seeking constructive criticism for their paper to improve its quality and effectiveness. They invite feedback on various aspects such as clarity, argument strength, and overall presentation, emphasizing the importance of diverse perspectives in refining their work.
  • #36
After taking in all your feedback, I submitted a new version of my paper, where instead the main result is called the simple result and is defined as a lemma, not a theorem. I also solved the "conjecture" in my paper and replaced it with a theorem, deriving an asymptotic for the roots of the Alternating Harmonic Numbers. I appreciate your feedback, it made a difference (for me at least)!

One small note, I wasn't able to cite Ramanujan because his Ramanujan summation appears in his notebooks, and I don't know how to cite them as they're unpublished. Hopefully mentioning his name in "Ramanujan Summation" should be enough to give him proper credit.
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
  • #37
I appreciate the little heads-up. Don't worry. I'm under no illusions that I can really contribute anything. All the best. :)
 
  • #38
sbrothy said:
I appreciate the little heads-up. Don't worry. I'm under no illusions that I can really contribute anything. All the best. :)
I think I can still cite his notebooks somehow. You have contributed something, don't downplay what you've done :)
 
  • Love
Likes sbrothy
Back
Top