Special relativity fundamental question

In summary: Yes, the book is correct and Eq. 1 has T from B's frame, because that is when A and B are the same point in space. From John's frame, however, T would be (v/c^2) X because that is when John is moving relative to A.
  • #1
krindik
65
1
Hi,
I'm very new to special relativity and have a very basic question.
A and B are moving from each other at a speed of [tex] v [/tex]
at some instant a light flashes in the space.
A records: At time [tex] t [/tex] a light flashed at [tex] x [/tex]
B records: At time [tex] t' [/tex] a light flashed at [tex] x' [/tex]

Here is what I understood from SR theory,
A, at time [tex] t [/tex] sees what B records (instantly, forgetting the delay to see B's record) and writes the relationship to match what he records [tex] (t, x) [/tex] and B records [tex] (t', x') [/tex]

[tex]x' = \gamma (x - vt)[/tex]
[tex]t' = \gamma (t - v/c^2 x)[/tex]
[tex]\gamma = 1/\sqrt{1 - v^2/c^2 }[/tex]

Is my understanding correct?

I am reading the wikibook http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Special_Relativity (hope that'll help me in all of special relativity)

Thanks in advance
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Yes, that is correct. The equations you have written (the first two specfically) are the Lorentz Transformation which relates position and time coordinates of an event as measured by the observers A and B, provided that one event has [itex]x = 0, t = 0[/itex] and [itex]x^{\prime} = 0, t^{\prime} = 0[/itex]. That is, the two coordinate systems are set up so their origins coincide.
 
  • #5
thanks for correcting
 
  • #6
One more question related to the same scenario from wikibook

1) How do you interpret the leaning forward of the time and x axis?
Can you give some hints from the attached image?

2)
The book says (Bill and John are moving from each at [tex]v[/tex])
So distances between two points according to Bill are simple lengths in space ([tex] X [/tex]) whereas John sees Bill's measurement of distance as a combination of a distance ([tex] x[/tex]) and a time interval:
[tex] x^2 = X^2 - (cT)^2 -----(1)[/tex]

But Bill's distance, [tex] x[/tex], is the length that he would obtain for things that John believes to be [tex] X[/tex] metres in length. For Bill it is John who has rods that contract in the direction of motion so Bill's determination "[tex] x[/tex]" of John's distance "[tex] X[/tex]" is given from:
[tex] x = X\sqrt{1 - v^2/c^2} -----(2) [/tex]

Eq. 2 is from the Lorentz tranform and Eq. 1 is from the space-time interval definition
But why does Eq. 1 has only [tex] T[/tex] from B's frame but not [tex] t[/tex] from John's frame?

Can u pls give some advice?

Actually I'm a bit confused as to how the interpretation that a moving objects are out of phase by [tex] T = (v/c^2) X[/tex] is derived. From that onwards I tend to wonder whether
the wikibook is correct and questioning everything... really sorry if this is a silly question...
 

Attachments

  • Relphasesimple.gif
    Relphasesimple.gif
    1.5 KB · Views: 488
Last edited:

FAQ: Special relativity fundamental question

What is special relativity?

Special relativity is a theory developed by Albert Einstein that explains how objects behave in the absence of external forces and under the influence of a constant velocity. It is based on the idea that the laws of physics should be the same for all observers regardless of their relative motion.

What is the fundamental question of special relativity?

The fundamental question of special relativity is how the laws of physics are affected by the relative motion of an observer and an object.

How is time affected by special relativity?

According to special relativity, time is relative and can appear to pass at different rates for different observers depending on their relative motion. This is known as time dilation.

Can objects really travel at the speed of light in special relativity?

No, according to special relativity, the speed of light is the maximum speed at which any object can travel. As an object approaches the speed of light, its mass and energy increase, making it impossible to reach the speed of light.

How does special relativity relate to general relativity?

Special relativity is a more specific theory that deals with objects in uniform motion, while general relativity is a more encompassing theory that includes the effects of gravity. Special relativity is a special case of general relativity when there is no gravitational force present.

Back
Top