Spread of Christianity: Irony of Violence and Peace

  • Thread starter klusener
  • Start date
In summary: Religions can be composed of people who are both peaceful and violent, just like any other group of people.However, in recent times, Hinduism has been perpetuated through violence, specifically with regards to the persecution of Christians in India.
  • #1
klusener
62
0
I truly find it ironic that the initial spread of Christianity and well into the 1900 hundreds, was through violence, what's ironic about this is that Jesus of Nazareth advocated peace and brotherhood, but his word spread around the world due to violence, like the Spanish conquistadors, etc... Why?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I want to emphasize that i am not undermining his teachings or Christians... this is just a question that has persisted in mind after one of my relatives told me about how one of his ancestors was shot by the British, after he refused to become a Christian...
 
  • #3
I believe that the answer to your question is that it simply IS ironic. I don't believe in any religion for many reasons, yours being one of them.

Anton
 
  • #4
Buddhism, another religion preaching peace, was spread by violent conquest in Southeast Asia.
 
  • #5
Most religions teach peace and most religions have at one time or another been spread via violence. Violence, historically, is simply the most effective way to spread any idea.
 
  • #6
klusener said:
I truly find it ironic that the initial spread of Christianity and well into the 1900 hundreds, was through violence, what's ironic about this is that Jesus of Nazareth advocated peace and brotherhood, but his word spread around the world due to violence, like the Spanish conquistadors, etc... Why?
Actually, the initial spread of Christianity was non-violent, it was not until over 300 years later when Constantice co-opted the religion, making it a state religion and enforcing it..did it become violent.
 
  • #7
selfAdjoint said:
Buddhism, another religion preaching peace, was spread by violent conquest in Southeast Asia.
I had never known that, do you have any good links for reference?
 
  • #8
I may be wrong (history, especialy religious history is not my strong suit), but i don't think Judaism was ever forcibly spread. They don't try to convert anyone.

Extenuating religions aside, I think Kat had it right the problem occurred when a government embraced a religion. That gave a religious bias to the enforcement of their laws and to any wars they engaged in.
 
Last edited:
  • #9
Christianity (and probably just about every religion) has spread both peacefully and forcefully. The questions is: "To what extent?"

Macgyver said:
I may be wrong (history, especialy religious history is not my strong suit), but i don't think Judaism was ever forcibly spread.

Would Israeli settlements (and the military protection thereof) count?
 
  • #10
Hinduism wasnt spread forcibly.
 
  • #11
chound said:
Hinduism wasnt spread forcibly.

But look at Hindu violence at present in India; murder of Christians, destruction of mosques, and mob violence condoned by the recent national government. Religions are composed of people, and true believing people can always be violent.
 
  • #12
chound said:
Hinduism wasnt spread forcibly.

What is your evidence for this. Hinduism was just a method to keep segregation in place.
 

FAQ: Spread of Christianity: Irony of Violence and Peace

How did Christianity spread despite the irony of violence and peace?

One of the main reasons for the spread of Christianity was the persecution of early Christians by the Roman Empire. The violence they faced only strengthened their faith and commitment to spreading their beliefs. Additionally, the peaceful teachings of Jesus and the promise of eternal life appealed to many people, leading to conversions and the spread of Christianity.

What role did violence play in the spread of Christianity?

Violence played a significant role in the spread of Christianity in the early centuries. The persecution and martyrdom of early Christians served as a powerful message to others, showing the strength and dedication of their faith. It also allowed for Christianity to gain attention and eventually gain acceptance as a legitimate religion.

How did the irony of peace and violence impact the perception of Christianity?

The irony of peace and violence in Christianity has been a topic of debate and criticism throughout history. Some view the use of violence, such as the Crusades, as contradictory to the peaceful teachings of Jesus. However, others argue that the violence was necessary for the spread and protection of the faith.

How did Christianity's spread affect other religions and cultures?

The spread of Christianity had a significant impact on other religions and cultures. As Christianity spread to different regions, it often incorporated local traditions and beliefs, leading to the development of different branches of Christianity. It also caused conflicts and tensions with other religions, as Christianity became the dominant religion in many areas.

What lessons can be learned from the irony of violence and peace in the spread of Christianity?

The irony of violence and peace in the spread of Christianity can teach us about the complexities of religion and the human experience. It highlights the power of belief and the lengths people will go to defend their faith. It also serves as a reminder to critically examine the actions of religious institutions and individuals, as they may not always align with the teachings of their faith.

Similar threads

Replies
25
Views
4K
Replies
25
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
38
Views
6K
Replies
29
Views
10K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Back
Top