- #36
PeterDonis
Mentor
- 46,951
- 23,385
No, it doesn't. You switched from vector to scalar. They're not the same thing.Jianbing_Shao said:In calculus. the path integral of a vector field with non-zero curl along different paths between two points will get different results. it just means that the movement of a scalar field is path dependent.
A vector has a curl. A scalar doesn't.Jianbing_Shao said:A vector only contains more components than a scalar.
You can define a path and vector field dependent "movement" in flat spacetime, sure. For example, in electrodynamics.Jianbing_Shao said:So we can define a path dependent movement in a flat spacetime.
What you can't do is use this to infer anything about the spacetime curvature or the path dependence of parallel transport that depends on spacetime curvature. Which means that your posts are irrelevant to this thread and are hijacking it.