Stuck on ladder problem, know the solution but need an explanation

In summary, a person standing on a ladder exerts forces on the floor and wall, with the floor exerting a normal and frictional force and the wall exerting only a normal force. To find these forces, the dimensions of the ladder and the person's weight must be taken into account in the calculation of torque. The given expression is not correct and is missing some dimensions.
  • #1
BifSlamkovich
24
0

Homework Statement


http://www.webassign.net/walker/p11-78alt.gif
An 85 kg person stands on a uniform ladder that is 4.3 m long and weighs 65.0 N. The floor is rough; hence it exerts both a normal force, f1, and a frictional force, f2, on the ladder. The wall, on the other hand, is frictionless; it exerts only a normal force, f3. Use the dimensions in the figure to find the following. (a = 3.8 m.)
f1=?
f2=?
f3=?


Homework Equations



I know the solution but I don't understand why f3(3.8)-mg(2.15)=0. How is this a correct expression of the torque?

The Attempt at a Solution

 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
BifSlamkovich said:

Homework Statement


http://www.webassign.net/walker/p11-78alt.gif
An 85 kg person stands on a uniform ladder that is 4.3 m long and weighs 65.0 N. The floor is rough; hence it exerts both a normal force, f1, and a frictional force, f2, on the ladder. The wall, on the other hand, is frictionless; it exerts only a normal force, f3. Use the dimensions in the figure to find the following. (a = 3.8 m.)
f1=?
f2=?
f3=?


Homework Equations



I know the solution but I don't understand why f3(3.8)-mg(2.15)=0. How is this a correct expression of the torque?

The Attempt at a Solution

It is not. The correct expression for torque about the base of the ladder must include f3, the man's weight, and the ladder weight, using the appropriate perpendicular diatances from those forces to the ladder base to calculate the respective torques and signs of the torques. You are missing a few dimensions.
 
  • #3


First of all, it is important to understand that torque is the measure of the force that can cause an object to rotate around an axis or pivot point. In this case, the axis of rotation is at the point where the ladder touches the ground, and the pivot point is where the ladder touches the wall.

To find the solution for f3, we need to use the equation for torque, which is given by τ = r x F, where τ is the torque, r is the distance from the pivot point, and F is the force applied.

In this problem, the torque due to f3 is equal to the weight of the ladder (mg) multiplied by the distance between the pivot point and the point where f3 is applied (which is 3.8 m). This is because the force of gravity is acting downwards on the ladder, and it is balanced by the normal force (f3) acting upwards at the pivot point. The equation can be written as τ = f3(3.8) - mg(2.15) = 0, since the ladder is not rotating, the net torque must be equal to zero.

Similarly, for f1, the torque is given by τ = f1(4.3) - mg(2.15) = 0. This is because f1 is acting at a distance of 4.3 m from the pivot point, and it is also balancing the weight of the ladder.

For f2, we need to consider both the normal force and the frictional force. The normal force is acting at a distance of 1.9 m from the pivot point, while the frictional force is acting at a distance of 2.15 m from the pivot point. The torque equation can be written as τ = f2(2.15) + f1(1.9) - mg(2.15) = 0, since both forces are acting in opposite directions and balancing each other out.

Overall, the key to understanding the solution is to recognize that torque is a measure of the force that causes rotation, and it is dependent on the distance from the pivot point. By balancing the torques in each direction, we can find the values of f1, f2, and f3.
 

FAQ: Stuck on ladder problem, know the solution but need an explanation

1. What is the "stuck on ladder" problem?

The "stuck on ladder" problem is a common physics problem where a person is trying to climb up a ladder that is leaning against a wall. The person is unable to reach the top of the ladder due to the ladder slipping or moving away from the wall.

2. What is the solution to the "stuck on ladder" problem?

The solution to the "stuck on ladder" problem involves using the principles of friction and static equilibrium. By creating enough friction between the ladder and the wall, the ladder will not slip and the person will be able to climb to the top.

3. How does friction play a role in solving the "stuck on ladder" problem?

Friction is the force that resists the motion between two surfaces in contact. In the "stuck on ladder" problem, friction is necessary to prevent the ladder from slipping away from the wall. Without enough friction, the ladder would slide down the wall and the person would not be able to reach the top.

4. What is static equilibrium and how does it help in solving the "stuck on ladder" problem?

Static equilibrium is a state in which all forces acting on an object are balanced and there is no net force or acceleration. In the "stuck on ladder" problem, static equilibrium is achieved when the downward force of the person's weight is balanced by the upward force of friction between the ladder and the wall.

5. Are there any other factors to consider when solving the "stuck on ladder" problem?

Yes, there are other factors to consider such as the angle of the ladder and the weight of the person. The angle of the ladder affects the amount of friction needed to prevent it from slipping, and the weight of the person affects the downward force that needs to be balanced. Additionally, the coefficient of friction between the ladder and the wall also plays a role in solving the problem.

Similar threads

Replies
8
Views
11K
Replies
28
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
4K
Replies
11
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
5K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
3K
Back
Top