Tales of irony My brother was telling me that the first time

  • Thread starter Ivan Seeking
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Time
In summary: Can you elaborate?In summary, my brother believes that the first time he ever lied was in confession and that the first time he ever told a lie was when he lied to the priest. The irony of these stories is not immediately apparent to him.
  • #1
Ivan Seeking
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
8,143
1,761
Tales of irony...

My brother was telling me that the first time that he remembers lying was in [Catholic] confession. It was his second time, and being about age seven, he didn't feel that he had done anything wrong since the last visit. But the nun, his teacher, insisted that he must have done something wrong. So he was instructed to go into the confessional and tell the priest what he has done. Since the little guy couldn't think of anything to say, he lied. What's more, he believes that this was the first time that he ever told a lie.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
that's...what is it?


what's the word?...bionic? no,


IRONIC! that was it! :rolleyes:
 
  • #3
Yes, that is a quintessentially ironic story.
 
  • #4
zoobyshoe said:
Yes, that is a quintessentially ironic story.


Yes, and he still hasn't gotten over it! :rolleyes:

...but that's another story...
 
  • #5
Okay, here's another one that comes to mind: The use of antibiotics leading to super-bugs that can't be killed.

Another funny one - though I'm sure not to the authorities - is what is supposed to be one of the most secret military installations in the world: Area 51, Groom Lake, Nevada. Has anyone not heard of this?
 
  • #6
That song "Isn't it Ironic" by Alanis Morissette was very ironic, because, as one comedian pointed out, all the examples of irony she used were not actually ironic at all. "Rain on your wedding day", is merely sad, not ironic.
 
  • #7
Ivan Seeking said:
Tales of irony...

My brother was telling me that the first time that he remembers lying was in [Catholic] confession. It was his second time, and being about age seven, he didn't feel that he had done anything wrong since the last visit. But the nun, his teacher, insisted that he must have done something wrong. So he was instructed to go into the confessional and tell the priest what he has done. Since the little guy couldn't think of anything to say, he lied. What's more, he believes that this was the first time that he ever told a lie.
Ha ha, that reminds me of a movie I saw...darn, can't recall the title...it was about the misadventures of a bunch of Catholic school boys (Heaven Help Us...maybe, or was that something else?). They're standing in line for the confessional, and one of them is really worried about admitting to masturbating or looking at some porn mags, so he asks the kid next to him, who instructs him that he can't possibly share that, so just add a few more lies to his list of sins and he'll be covered.

I did the same thing as a kid...er...that is lie in confession...when forced to go to confession, it was common to make up stuff that sounded believable, "I didn't listen to my parents once and I lied a few times." That's probably why the Catholic school kids in my town were so much worse than us public school kids. They had to go to confession every week, so if you're going to have to confess to stuff, you might as well go ahead and do it. :biggrin:
 
  • #8
zoobyshoe said:
That song "Isn't it Ironic" by Alanis Morissette was very ironic, because, as one comedian pointed out, all the examples of irony she used were not actually ironic at all. "Rain on your wedding day", is merely sad, not ironic.
:smile: Yes, I've noticed that too. I still like the song though. It's hard to find good examples of real irony.
 
  • #9
Irony? Isn't that a bit like goldy or bronzey only it's made of iron?
 
  • #10
I had this shirt made of rayon. Whenever it was washed and put into the dryer it got puckered and was quite unwearable. Usually I washed it again and let it hang-dry and then it was still puckered but at least wearable, and after a while it looked quite normal.

Then once I tried to iron out the puckers. The iron caused it to wrinkle up like a prune. Beat THAT irony!
 
  • #11
Monday morning I was in class and my professor made a comment about creationism being enforced in Kansas public schools. He mentioned some Christian churches making public anti-gay protests. Later that day I saw the news and there was a large group of Christian church members from Kansas that were bused out here to protest schools in several Massachusetts cities. Tuesday I asked the professor if he had heard the news report before class on the previous day. He hadn't. Should I ask the protestors if they heard my professor?
 
  • #12
Huckleberry:

First of all, thank you for averting my "threadkiller" position on this thread. Second, I don't see the irony, yet.
 

FAQ: Tales of irony My brother was telling me that the first time

What is "Tales of Irony My Brother Was Telling Me"?

"Tales of Irony My Brother Was Telling Me" is a collection of stories or anecdotes shared by the narrator's brother that exhibit ironic situations or events.

What is the purpose of these tales?

The purpose of these tales is to entertain and possibly make a commentary on the human condition and the absurdity of life.

Are these tales based on real events?

It is unclear if these tales are based on real events or if they are fictional. The narrator's brother could be using hyperbole or exaggeration in his storytelling.

Why is irony important in literature?

Irony adds depth and complexity to a story by presenting a contrast between what is expected and what actually happens. It can also reveal deeper truths about human behavior and society.

Can irony be used in scientific research?

Yes, irony can be used in scientific research as a tool to highlight unexpected or contrary results. It can also be used in a satirical or critical way to challenge established ideas or beliefs.

Back
Top