In summary: Your Name]In summary, the conversation discussed the relationship between the definition of the electric field as seen by an observer and the Lorentz Transformation of the Electric Field. The definition of the electric field takes into account the observer's relative motion and is expressed as an observer-dependent 4-vector, while the transformation is a mathematical tool used to transform the electric field from one reference frame to another. It was also noted that the Lorentz Transformation does not change the physical nature of the electric field, but simply shows how it appears to different observers. It was also mentioned that a deeper understanding of general relativity is necessary to fully understand electromagnetic fields.
  • #1
robphy
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
7,009
2,492
This Insight was inspired by the discussion in “electric field seen by an observer in motion“, which tries to understand the relation between two expressions:

the definition of the electric field as seen by an observer (expressed as an observer-dependent 4-vector, as decomposed from the Maxwell field tensor ##E_{a}=F_{ab}v^b##, as found in Wald’s General Relativity [p. 64, Eq (4.2.21)] )
the Lorentz Transformation of the Electric Field, in 3-vector form

I was going to reply to a comment on something I said (here) but then realized that my post was getting too large. So, here it is in the Insight.
[itex]\def\MACROS{}
\def\hv{\hat v}
\def\hw{\hat w}...

Continue reading...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
  • Love
Likes Ibix, vanhees71, aliens123 and 4 others
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Hello,

Thank you for bringing this discussion to my attention. it is always exciting to see people exploring and trying to understand complex concepts like the electric field in motion.

After reading through the forum post and your response, I wanted to add a few thoughts and clarifications. Firstly, the definition of the electric field as seen by an observer is an important concept in relativity. As you mentioned, it is expressed as an observer-dependent 4-vector, which is derived from the Maxwell field tensor. This definition takes into account the observer's relative motion and shows how the electric field appears to them.

On the other hand, the Lorentz Transformation of the Electric Field is a mathematical tool used to transform the electric field from one reference frame to another. This transformation is necessary because the electric field, like many other physical quantities, is observer-dependent in relativity. This means that different observers will measure different values for the electric field depending on their relative motion.

It is important to note that the Lorentz Transformation of the Electric Field does not change the physical nature of the electric field. It simply shows how the field appears to different observers. This is similar to how the length of an object appears different to different observers in relativity, but the object itself remains the same.

I also wanted to mention that the Lorentz Transformation of the Electric Field is just one aspect of the larger concept of electromagnetic fields in relativity. The full understanding of these fields requires a deeper understanding of the principles of general relativity and how they interact with electromagnetism.

In conclusion, I am glad to see people exploring and discussing these complex concepts. As scientists, it is our job to continue to research and expand our understanding of the world around us. I hope this helps clarify some aspects of the discussion. Keep up the great work!

 

FAQ: The Electric Field Seen by an Observer: A Relativistic Calculation with Tensors

What is the concept of an electric field seen by an observer?

The concept of an electric field seen by an observer is based on the theory of relativity, which states that measurements of physical quantities such as electric fields can vary depending on the observer's frame of reference. This means that the electric field observed by one observer may appear differently to another observer who is moving at a different velocity.

How is the electric field seen by an observer calculated using tensors?

Tensors are mathematical objects that are used to describe the properties of physical systems in a way that is independent of the observer's frame of reference. In the context of calculating the electric field seen by an observer, tensors are used to transform the components of the electric field from one frame of reference to another, taking into account the effects of relativity.

What is the significance of the relativistic calculation of the electric field seen by an observer?

The relativistic calculation of the electric field seen by an observer is significant because it helps us understand the effects of relativity on the behavior of electric fields. This is important in fields such as particle physics and cosmology, where the behavior of particles and fields is affected by their relative velocities.

Can the electric field seen by an observer be measured experimentally?

Yes, the electric field seen by an observer can be measured experimentally. However, the measurements may differ depending on the observer's frame of reference, as predicted by the theory of relativity. This is why it is important to use tensors to accurately calculate and compare the electric field measurements made by different observers.

How does the concept of an electric field seen by an observer relate to the larger theory of relativity?

The concept of an electric field seen by an observer is just one example of how the theory of relativity affects our understanding of physical phenomena. It demonstrates that physical quantities such as electric fields are not absolute, but can vary depending on the observer's frame of reference. This is a fundamental principle of relativity that applies to many other physical quantities and has implications for our understanding of the universe.

Back
Top