- #1
brianthewhitie7
- 17
- 0
If you were the only object in space and you were not moving would you feel time (also spacetime is not moving either)?
The Feeling of Time Alone in Space
- Thread starter brianthewhitie7
- Start date
In summary, if you were the only object in space and you were not moving, you would still observe the passing of time. However, without any other objects to make measurements, the concept of motion would not make sense. The idea of one object in the universe is also problematic as it raises questions about what defines a single object. Therefore, the question of whether one would feel time in this scenario is more of a philosophical one rather than a physical one.
- #2
rbj
- 2,227
- 10
spacetime [itex] \ne [/itex] aether
- #3
sweetser
Gold Member
- 360
- 0
If you were the only object, there would be no way to make any measurements. You would continue to exist is spacetime.
- #4
russ_watters
Mentor
- 23,482
- 10,812
Certainly, you can still count and you would still age...
- #5
bernhard.rothenstein
- 991
- 1
single observer
Has this "only object" a wrist watch?brianthewhitie7 said:
- #6
brianthewhitie7
- 17
- 0
Well what i was getting at if you could get your speed to zero while time was not moving would you not progress in time. And we know that if go the speed of light then time would stop so i was just trying to find another way time would stop.
- #7
russ_watters
Mentor
- 23,482
- 10,812
That really doesn't make a whole lot of sense, but yes, if you could stop time, time would stop (brianthewhitie7 said:
). And your speed with respect to yourself and light is always zero. So in the context of your original post, you are always stationary.
Last edited:
- #8
pmb_phy
- 2,952
- 1
Yes, you would observe the passing of time, or as you would say "feel time."brianthewhitie7 said:
Pete
- #9
- 10,338
- 1,516
brianthewhitie7 said:
I think the best answer is that you would indeed suffer while you suffocated from no air to breathe - but probably not for very long. (Just what one would expect from a sudden vacuum exposure).
If you assume that you had air to breathe, water to drink, food to eat, and some sort of system to recylce them, you'd hardly be "the only object in space".
- #10
Mentz114
- 5,432
- 292
If you were the only object in the universe, the idea of motion makes no sense. Motion is relative.
- #11
Ich
Science Advisor
- 1,931
- 1
Right. It doesn't matter anyway. Relativity always happens to other people, not oneself. That's where the name comes from: it deals with relations, not physical changes caused by absolute velocities.
- #12
pmb_phy
- 2,952
- 1
In fact the observer himself will never detect any changes in the flow of time if he checks his clock, in principle that is. Living in deep space for a while may mess with your observations.Mentz114 said:
Pete
- #13
Mentz114
- 5,432
- 292
Greetings, Pete. Yes, and the idea of 'one thing' is also problematical. When is a thing one thing, as opposed to several things stuck together ? The OPs question as posed is devoid of physical meaning. That means it must be philosophy so I'm out of here.
You'll definitely need the winter underwear.
FAQ: The Feeling of Time Alone in Space
What is "The Feeling of Time Alone in Space"?
"The Feeling of Time Alone in Space" is a psychological phenomenon experienced by astronauts, which refers to the feeling of being isolated and detached from the rest of humanity while in space.
What causes this feeling?
This feeling is caused by a combination of factors such as the vastness and emptiness of space, the lack of familiar surroundings and people, and the inability to communicate with loved ones on Earth.
Does every astronaut experience this feeling?
Not every astronaut experiences this feeling, as it can vary from person to person. Factors such as personality, coping mechanisms, and the duration of the space mission can influence the intensity of this feeling.
Are there any negative effects of "The Feeling of Time Alone in Space"?
While this feeling can be unsettling, it is a normal and temporary reaction to the unique environment of space. However, if it becomes too overwhelming, it can lead to psychological issues such as anxiety, depression, and feelings of isolation.
How do astronauts cope with this feeling?
Astronauts undergo extensive psychological training and are equipped with various coping mechanisms to manage this feeling. They also have support systems in place, such as regular communication with mission control and fellow astronauts, to help them cope with the challenges of being alone in space.