- #1
Peter Morgan
Gold Member
- 274
- 77
My paper "Classical states, quantum field measurement", arXiv:1709.06711, has been accepted by Physica Scripta, https://doi.org/10.1088/1402-4896/ab0c53. The version as submitted to Physica Scripta on November 4th, 2018 is available as arXiv:1709.06711v5.
I believe that anyone who puts some effort into understanding the mathematical construction will find it worthwhile: the referee said of the paper, for example, that there is a "density of ideas" and that the mathematics is "elegant" (as did another person, last Summer, of an earlier version).
Any comments here that might help me write a better next paper will be very welcome. Some here may even feel the need to explain why some of it is nonsense, which would be only right insofar as my interpretation of the mathematics is not, I think, as solid as the mathematics. Finally, a blog post discusses the larger changes I introduced as a result of my discussions with the referee.
I believe that anyone who puts some effort into understanding the mathematical construction will find it worthwhile: the referee said of the paper, for example, that there is a "density of ideas" and that the mathematics is "elegant" (as did another person, last Summer, of an earlier version).
Any comments here that might help me write a better next paper will be very welcome. Some here may even feel the need to explain why some of it is nonsense, which would be only right insofar as my interpretation of the mathematics is not, I think, as solid as the mathematics. Finally, a blog post discusses the larger changes I introduced as a result of my discussions with the referee.