"Thread Closed" status not indicated in Alerts list

  • Bug
  • Thread starter symbolipoint
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the system of Alerts and how to access posts or topics through the list. It is mentioned that sometimes threads or topics in the Alerts list are closed, but it is not indicated on the list. Only when signed in and visiting an Alert item, it can be observed that there is no 'reply' link, indicating the thread or topic is closed. The last post of the topic may also state that it is closed. It is mentioned that eventually all threads get closed and this is part of the archived knowledge base. These old threads still have value as people can find them through Google searches and learn from them. The view count on the alert list can continue to grow year by year, even after the thread is closed.
  • #1
symbolipoint
Homework Helper
Education Advisor
Gold Member
7,407
1,876
We have the system of Alerts and the tool to open that list, and visit any post or topic in the Alerts list. Sometimes a thread or topic for a listing in the Alerts list is CLOSED; but the item in the Alerts list shows no indication that the 'thread is closed'. Only if we are signed in and are sharp enough would we find that upon visiting one of our Alert items, that none of the posts have a 'reply' link, and that we may intelligently guess that the thread or topic is now closed. And then the last post of the topic will show the moderator posted for whatever reason that "thread is closed".

Eventually, most if not all members visiting that topic will find that it is closed, but it may not appear immediately obvious.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Eventually, all threads get closed. Look at threads from 10 or more years in the past, they are all closed. It is part of our archived knowledge base.

Those old threads still have value. People find them by google searching for phrases. They don't need to be PF members. A person can get there by search, read and learn from the thread, and never notice how old the thread it. To him, the age is irrelevant. It is also irrelevant if the thread is closed if he just wants to learn by reading, not posting. If the person is not registered on PF, he can't post anyhow.

One thing you do see on the alert list is the view count. That count continues to grow year by year. Sometimes, the number of views after the last post far exceed the views during the time the thread was active.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes dextercioby and dlgoff
  • #3
anorlunda said:
Look at threads from 10 or more years in the past, they are all closed. It is part of our archived knowledge base.
I was on another board where they keep threads open forever and don't allow new threads on the same topics (and merge any that were). You had to be a bit careful answering the early posts because some members have died.
 
  • #4
  • #5
StevieTNZ said:
Rt Hon @Greg Bernhardt - is this a bug or a suggestion?
You asking the administrator? I am who asked about this topic. I chose "bug", but am not insisting on the topic being a suggestion. It is more an OBSERVATION, and allows for some explanation.
 
  • #6
symbolipoint said:
You asking the administrator?
Yes.
 

FAQ: "Thread Closed" status not indicated in Alerts list

1. What does "Thread Closed" status mean in the Alerts list?

The "Thread Closed" status in the Alerts list indicates that a discussion or conversation has been ended and can no longer be replied to or participated in.

2. Why is the "Thread Closed" status not indicated in the Alerts list?

The "Thread Closed" status may not be indicated in the Alerts list because the platform or system does not have the capability to track and display this information. It could also be a design choice to keep the Alerts list clean and concise.

3. Can a closed thread be reopened?

It depends on the platform or system. Some may allow the thread to be reopened by a moderator or administrator, while others may have a permanent closure policy where threads cannot be reopened.

4. How can I tell if a thread is closed if it's not indicated in the Alerts list?

If the "Thread Closed" status is not indicated in the Alerts list, you can check the thread itself to see if it has been marked as closed. This information may also be available in the thread's title or description.

5. Is there a way to receive alerts for closed threads?

This depends on the platform or system. Some may have an option to receive alerts for closed threads, while others may not have this feature. You can check the platform's settings or contact the administrator for more information.

Similar threads

Replies
23
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
20
Views
6K
Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
21
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top