Thread Hijacking: Rules and Etiquette

  • Thread starter Lisa!
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the topic of thread hijacking and the appropriate actions to take in such a situation. One participant has been given permission from the original poster to take the thread in a new direction, but generally thread hijacking is discouraged. The conversation also mentions the possibility of splitting a discussion into two separate discussions if needed.
  • #1
Lisa!
Gold Member
649
98
when and where is allowed?

For example do you think I'm allwed to hijack this thread now? :rolleyes:
It was very nice of Pengwuino when he let me to do that, but I think I still needs the mentor's permission!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
No response yet? :rolleyes:

I think that means "Do what the hell you want to do, but don't expect me to give you the permission". something like "Suppose I'm not see what you're doing!" :zzz:
 
  • #3
This kind of 'issue' shouldn't really need mentor's to sort out. More appropriate would be the original poster PMing the hijacker.

In more extreme cases, where many people hijack a thread, a post by the OP should be done to indicate he/she/it's annoyance at such intrusion. If not, THEN mentoring action is required.

I think that means "Do what the hell you want to do, but don't expect me to give you the permission". something like "Suppose I'm not see what you're doing!"

How about giving them some time to respond? Rather than being rather impatient?
 
  • #4
If you think a thread is being hijacked, even if you were not the originator, REPORT the post! The "Report Bad Post" button on the lower left-hand side of each post is there for a reason.

I STRONGLY suggest you do NOT PM the "hijacker". Such things can and usually WILL deteorate into something unpleasent. Let the administrators and the mentors handle such things.

Zz.
 
  • #5
Thanks for your suggestions. But in this case it's me who want to hijack a thread and the OP has given me the permission
and I don't think others have any problem with that too. :rolleyes:
Bladibla said:
How about giving them some time to respond? Rather than being rather impatient?
Yep, you're right. I'm too impatient and I always try to be patient but I can't! :shy:
 
  • #6
There's a difference between hijacking a thread and following a discussion along a natural path that might be somewhat different from the original intent of the poster. Since you have permission from the OP to take it in the new direction, it should not be a problem, but generally, thread hijacking is frowned upon. If a discussion does wind up taking two paths and folks wish to pursue both of them, it's possible for the mentors to split a discussion into two discussions so that the second topic doesn't distract from the first. If that needs to be done, let a mentor know.
 

FAQ: Thread Hijacking: Rules and Etiquette

Is hijacking a thread allowed in scientific forums?

No, hijacking a thread is not allowed in scientific forums as it disrupts the flow of discussion and can lead to confusion or misinformation.

Can hijacking a thread be beneficial in any way?

In general, hijacking a thread is not beneficial as it can derail the original topic and prevent others from contributing to the discussion. However, if the hijacking is done in a respectful and relevant manner, it may add new perspectives to the conversation.

Are there any consequences for hijacking a thread?

Consequences for hijacking a thread may vary depending on the platform. In some cases, it may result in a warning or temporary ban, while in others it may result in a permanent ban. It is important to follow the rules and guidelines of the specific forum or platform to avoid any consequences.

What should I do if I notice someone hijacking a thread?

If you notice someone hijacking a thread, you can report it to the moderators or admins of the forum or platform. They will then review the situation and take appropriate action.

How can I prevent my thread from being hijacked?

To prevent your thread from being hijacked, it is important to clearly state the topic and purpose of the discussion in the original post. Additionally, you can set guidelines for the discussion and ask others to stick to the topic. If someone does attempt to hijack the thread, politely redirect the conversation back to the original topic.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
25
Views
2K
Replies
21
Views
2K
Replies
169
Views
8K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
22
Views
2K
Replies
26
Views
3K
Back
Top