- #36
PeterDonis
Mentor
- 47,494
- 23,766
Chris Miller said:I guess I see Earth's FOR as including a vast region of space at which it is at the center and not moving relative to
Is this frame rotating or not? You can pick either answer: both are valid. But you have to be clear about which you are using. And then you have to realize that answers to other questions can depend on which you pick. If you pick the non-rotating frame (which is often called an "Earth-Centered Inertial" frame in the literature), then yes, the satellite is moving relative to this frame. But if you pick the rotating frame (which is often called "Earth-Centered Earth-Fixed"), the satellite is not moving. So whether the satellite is moving depends on which one you pick: there is no unique answer to the question.