Two Block Problem: Solving for Forces (Parts b & c)

  • Thread starter ZanyCat
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Block
In summary, the conversation discusses a physics question involving two blocks and the calculation of the force between them. The speaker correctly solved for the force in part (a) but is confused about the concept in part (b). They question where the additional force of 2.1N comes from and clarify that only one force should be acting in part (b).
  • #1
ZanyCat
21
0
g3KVyFa.png


I'm sure you guys have never answered a physics question involving two blocks before :P

My question is regarding parts (b) and, by extension, (c).

For part (a), I called the force between the two blocks 'z' and solved [tex]\frac{F - z}{m1} = \frac{z}{m2} [/tex] which gave me z = 1.1N, which was correct.

Conceptually for part (b), I imagined the two blocks as one system. Two forces are acting on the system in opposite directions and they have the same magnitude, so the system is in equilibirum and not accelerating. Now considering just the large mass, this must be in equilibrium also, as it must not be accelerating either. Thus to oppose the F force pushing right, the z force 'pushing' left on it from the smaller block must have the same magnitude as F, 3.2N.
When I solved a pair of simultaneous equations again, I also ended up with z = 3.2N.

So where is my thinking wrong? Where does the 2.1N come from?

Thanks :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
In part (b), I think they mean that the force is removed from m1 and applied to m2, so there is only 1 force acting.
 
  • #3
ap123 said:
In part (b), I think they mean that the force is removed from m1 and applied to m2, so there is only 1 force acting.
Right, otherwise the problem does not make sense.
You can calculate the force as in (a).
 

FAQ: Two Block Problem: Solving for Forces (Parts b & c)

What is the Two Block Problem?

The Two Block Problem is a physics problem that involves finding the forces acting on two blocks connected by a string or rope. This problem is commonly used to illustrate concepts such as tension, friction, and Newton's laws of motion.

What is the purpose of solving for forces in this problem?

The purpose of solving for forces in the Two Block Problem is to understand the relationship between the masses of the blocks, the tension in the rope, and the forces of friction acting on the blocks. It also helps to demonstrate how these forces affect the motion and acceleration of the blocks.

How do you solve for forces in the Two Block Problem?

To solve for forces in the Two Block Problem, you must first draw a free body diagram for each block, identifying all the forces acting on them. Then, you can use Newton's second law (F=ma) to set up equations and solve for the unknown forces.

What are some common challenges when solving for forces in this problem?

One common challenge when solving for forces in the Two Block Problem is determining the direction of the forces. This requires careful attention to the sign conventions and understanding the components of the forces in different directions. Another challenge is accounting for the effects of friction, which can complicate the equations and require additional calculations.

How can solving for forces in the Two Block Problem be applied to real-world situations?

The Two Block Problem has many real-world applications, such as in pulley systems, elevator systems, and even in analyzing the forces acting on a person walking with a backpack. By understanding how forces interact in this problem, we can better understand the mechanics of everyday objects and systems.

Back
Top