Understanding Image Formation: Exploring the Role of Photons and Detectors

In summary, an image forms when a lens focuses light onto a surface, such as the retina of the eye or photographic film, in a way that correlates the intensity of light reflected from an object with the intensity at each point on the surface. Photons do not play a role in this process, which is based on classical electrodynamics and optics. The photons, or electromagnetic waves, reflected off an object form an image in every location in a room, but it is not until the eye, acting as a detector, is at a specific location to gather the information from the time-varying fields that the image is generated.
  • #36
sophiecentaur said:
Did you notice the title? Photons observed as Particles and Waves. Of course photons can be 'observed' one way or another and, under special conditions (as in the experiments described) both behaviours can be observed. I saw that the word Duality appears three times in that reference; once in a quote from Feynman (not recent) and twice in the words of the journalist, reporting on the experiment. Have you ever had your words quoted by a journalist? It is not always a reliable process.
But does this really have anything at all to do with the situation of the scale that is described in the OP? The answer to that question is available with simple ray optics. The general opinion of PF is that photons do not help with that question.

Your statement verbatim that duality has been discarded is in complete contradiction to what you just said. You just stated that photons can be observed to be particle like and wave like. That is what duality is. This experiment shows a possible superposition of those properties. This is not the only recent observation of similar phenomena
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #37
waves and change said:
Duality being discarded? Please site references explaining that?

It has been discussed here multiple times... E.g. read this:
https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/why-does-wave-particle-duality-not-exist-anymore.910647/

Ever since quantum mechanics was developed, wave-particle duality is treated only as a heuristic, not any part of a mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics, nor quantum field theory. Reference? Most of textbooks on QM or QFT.
 
  • #38
waves and change said:
I suggest you look into this regarding your statement that particles behave as particles and waves behave as waves which is incorrect in many contexts.
https://www.photonics.com/a52250/Photons_Observed_as_Particles_Waves
That is a non-technical PR summary intended for laypeople, so is not an acceptable reference under the physics forums rules (and the phrase "Artist’s impression, inspired by the work of the artist Maurits Cornelis Escher" is something of a warning here). The actual published paper (available free after a mildly annoying registration process) is much more serious but doesn't do much to support any of the informally stated English-language positions being argued in the last few posts.

In any case, we are far off the topic of the original post and thread title, so we can close the thread. Further questions on the nature of photons and the status of wave-particle duality in modern (after 1925) quantum physics should be started in new threads - but please please take a look at some of the many threads on these topics that we already have.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes sophiecentaur and weirdoguy

Similar threads

Replies
152
Views
7K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
21
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Back
Top