- #36
WannabeNewton
Science Advisor
- 5,844
- 552
To conclude, I think this is the whole crux of it all. If the goal is to learn the physics then yeah go right into the relevant physics text but there will be people, me included, who are just uncomfortable in learning physical theories at the level of GR or QM etc. without some exposition to the math as presented in a math text, beforehand.LastOneStanding said:More importantly, it makes it possible to start understanding the physics as quickly as possible.
However I think GR is funny in the sense that even if you do learn differential geometry from a math text beforehand, you will still not be able to do any of the problems involving tensor calculus (like the one I posted a solution to in post #7 of this thread) until you actually pick up a GR book and start reading it because as far as I've seen, no modern differential geometry text even touches the index based tensor calculations that you see so pervasively in e.g. Wald.