There is no absolute "at once" for all observers. Simultaneity is relative. I guess that is your problem, but you have to describe your reasoning more accurately.keepitmoving said:photon being in more than one place at once? I realize there can be a problem of simultaneity which i don`t understand.
keepitmoving said:i know i`m on the simple side but here goes - if a moving emitter sends a photon out and the photon moves at c away from the moving emitter such that the photon is always at c x time distance from the moving emitter, then that photon has a position at any instant. If another observer is moving in the opposite direction from the moving emitter and he also measures that same photon, then his c x time from his position to the photon would yield a different position for the photon. They`re both using c as the speed and using the same time so that should yield different positions for the photon. I must be haywire here. Sorry. Your help is appreciated.
That's true in the frame of the emitter, using that frame's distance and time measurements.keepitmoving said:i know i`m on the simple side but here goes - if a moving emitter sends a photon out and the photon moves at c away from the moving emitter such that the photon is always at c x time distance from the moving emitter
OK., then that photon has a position at any instant.
No, the same photon has a single position. What's different are the coordinates of that position. That second observer will measure the photon's distance from him using his own distance and time measurements.If another observer is moving in the opposite direction from the moving emitter and he also measures that same photon, then his c x time from his position to the photon would yield a different position for the photon.
No. Same position, just differently described.They`re both using c as the speed and using the same time so that should yield different positions for the photon.
The problem of simultaneity refers to the concept that two events happening at the same time may appear differently to different observers. This is due to the fact that the speed of light is constant, and as a result, the perception of time and space can vary for different observers.
The dual nature of light refers to its ability to behave as both a wave and a particle. This duality is what causes the problem of simultaneity, as the perception of light as a wave or a particle can affect the way events are perceived by different observers.
Understanding the problem of simultaneity is crucial in many areas of science, particularly in the fields of physics and astronomy. It helps us to accurately interpret and measure the behavior of light and other phenomena, and can also lead to advancements in technology and our understanding of the universe.
Scientists have used various theories and experiments to try and understand the problem of simultaneity. This includes Einstein's theory of relativity, which explains how the perception of time and space can be affected by the speed of light, and the use of high-tech equipment to measure and observe light and its behavior.
Understanding the problem of simultaneity has led to the development of technologies such as GPS systems, which rely on the accurate measurement of time and space. It has also played a crucial role in the development of quantum mechanics and has implications for the study of black holes and other phenomena in the universe.